Dimethandrolone (DMA: 7α,11β-dimethyl-19-nortestosterone) and 11β-methyl-19-nortestosterone (MNT) are potent androgens in development for hormonal therapy in men. As <em>5α</em>-reduced androgens, such as <em>5α</em>-dihydrotestosterone (<em>DHT</em>), may raise the risk of benign prostate hyperplasia, accelerate the development of prostate carcinoma, and increase male pattern baldness and acne, we investigated the role of <em>5α</em>-reduction in the androgenic activity of DMA and MNT. The authentic <em>5α</em>-reduced metabolites, <em>5α</em>-dihydroDMA (<em>5α</em>-DHDMA) and <em>5α</em>-dihydroMNT (<em>5α</em>-DHMNT), were prepared by chemical synthesis and compared in vitro and in vivo to the parent compounds. Both <em>5α</em>-reduced androgens bound with high affinity to the rat androgen receptor (AR) and were potent inducers of transactivation of 3XHRE-LUC in CV-1 cells cotransfected with a human AR expression plasmid. To examine in vivo androgenic (stimulation of ventral prostate [VP] and seminal vesicle [SV] weights) and anabolic (stimulation of levator ani [LA] muscle weights) activity, 22-day-old castrate male rats were treated sc for 7 days with various doses of DMA, <em>5α</em>-DHDMA, or testosterone (T) or MNT, <em>5α</em>-DHMNT, or T and necropsied on day 8. <em>5α</em>-DHDMA was at least threefold more potent than T in stimulating growth of the VP but only 30-40% as potent as DMA. <em>5α</em>-DHMNT was four- to eightfold more potent than T, whereas MNT was approximately equipotent to T. To assess the possible role of <em>5α</em>-reduction in VP and SV growth, castrate immature rats were treated with maximally effective doses of T, <em>DHT</em>, DMA, MNT, or the related 19-norandrogen, 7α-methyl-19-nortestosterone (MENT), or vehicle, with or without dutasteride (DUT), an inhibitor of <em>5α</em>-reductases types 1 and 2. In rats treated with T+DUT, serum T was significantly higher (P<0.05) than in rats treated with T alone, and serum <em>DHT</em> was decreased (P<0.001) to levels observed in castrate vehicle-treated rats. DUT significantly reduced both VP and SV weights in T-treated rats, whereas there was no significant effect of DUT on weights of these accessory sex glands in rats treated with DMA, MNT, <em>DHT</em>, or MENT. These results indicate that inhibition of <em>5α</em>-reductase activity in vivo does not affect the androgenic potency of DMA, MNT, or MENT.