We previously demonstrated that, in rat pancreatic acinar cells, the high-affinity cholecystokinin (<em>CCK</em>) receptor agonist JMV-180 utilizes the phospholipase <em>A</em>2 (PL<em>A</em>2) cascade to mediate Ca2+ oscillations and amylase secretion. In contrast, the low-affinity <em>CCK</em> receptor utilizes the phospholipase C beta 1 (PLC beta 1) pathway. We have investigated structural requirements of <em>CCK</em> analogues to activate different intracellular pathways. <em>CCK</em> analogues such as <em>CCK</em>-8 [Met28,31; half-maximal effective concentration (EC50) = 0.4 pM], <em>CCK</em>-7 (Met28,31; EC50 = 0.7 pM), and NON<em>A</em> (Thr28/Nle31; EC50 = 5 pM) caused a biphasic amylase secretion. Reduction of secretion occurred with high doses of these peptides >> 100 pM). In contrast, <em>CCK</em>-5 (Met31; EC50 = 20,000pM), JMV-180 (Nle28,31; 1,500 pM), and OPE (Nle28,31; 200 pM) caused a monophasic secretion. <em>CCK</em>-8, but not JMV-180, increased protein kinase C (PKC) activities. The PKC activator phorbol ester inhibited an increase in myo-inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate levels induced by <em>CCK</em>-8 and abolished monophasic amylase secretion induced by OPE. <em>CCK</em>-8, <em>CCK</em>-7, and NON<em>A</em> caused Ca2+ oscillations (< 100 pM) or large Ca2+ transients >> 100 pM). In contrast, JMV-180 and OPE evoked Ca2+ oscillations, even in high doses. Ca(2+)-signaling modes induced by <em>CCK</em>-5 were intermediate types between <em>CCK</em>-8 and JMV-180. <em>CCK</em>-8- and <em>CCK</em>-7-stimulated Ca2+ spikes were inhibited by the PLC inhibitor U-73122, but not by the PL<em>A</em>2 inhibitor ONO-RS-082. The action of <em>CCK</em>-5 was only partially sensitive to the PLC inhibitor. In contrast, JMV-180- and OPE-stimulated Ca2+ oscillations were inhibited by the PL<em>A</em>2, but not by the PLC, inhibitor. NON<em>A</em> was sensitive to PLC and PL<em>A</em>2 inhibitors. <em>A</em>lthough JMV-180 differs from <em>CCK</em>-8 by having an <em>A</em>sp-2 phenylethylester, rather than an <em>A</em>sp-phenylalanine amide, it is unlikely that these differences in the carboxyl terminus are important in determining which second-messenger systems will be activated. This is because <em>CCK</em>-5 (Phe33-CONH2) causes monophasic amylase secretion and Ca2+ oscillation in a manner similar to those induced by JMV-180 (2-phenylethylester). Meanwhile NON<em>A</em> (Phe33-CONH2) appeared to activate PLC and PL<em>A</em>2 pathways. The actions of all <em>CCK</em> analogues were abolished by L-364,718, indicating mediation by <em>CCK</em>-<em>A</em> receptors. Therefore, depending on the agonists used, <em>CCK</em>-<em>A</em> receptor activation in pancreatic acini may result in differential involvement of second-messenger systems, Ca2+ signal transduction, and amylase secretion. On the basis of the amino acid sequence of the carboxy terminus of <em>CCK</em> analogues, it appears that key amino acids for this differentiation are Met28 (or Thr28) for PLC pathways and Nle28 for PL<em>A</em>2 pathways.