The creatine kinase system and pleiotropic effects of creatine

Creatine and creatine kinase

Although ATP represents the universal energy currency in all organisms and cells, ATP levels are not simply up-regulated in cells with high and/or intermittently fluctuating energy demand. Elevation of the intracellular ATP concentration [ATP], as an immediate energy reserve, followed by its hydrolysis, would lead to a massive accumulation of ADP plus P_i and also liberate H⁺, acidifying the cytosol. Since this would inhibit ATPases, such as the myofibrillar acto-myosin ATPase and consequently muscle contraction, and many other cellular processes, nature has evolved a means to deal with the problem of the immediate replenishment of ATP stores. The so-called phosphagens evolved as high-energy compounds that are “metabolically inert” and as such do not interfere with primary metabolism. One of them, PCr, together with its corresponding kinase, CK, first appeared at the dawn of eukaryotic evolution some one billion years ago (Bertin et al. 2007).

CK catalyses the reversible reaction: \documentclass[12pt]{minimal}\usepackage{amsmath}\usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy}\usepackage{mathrsfs}\usepackage{upgreek}\setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt}\begin{document}$$ {\text{PCr}}^{2 - } + {\text{MgADP}}^{ - } {\text{ + H}}^{ + } \triangleleft - {\text{CK}} - \triangleright {\text{MgATP}}^{2 - } {\text{ + Cr}} $$\end{document}and can thus either utilize PCr (with a higher ∆G free energy change than ATP) to regenerate ATP or alternatively capture immediately available cellular energy, storing up to 10 times the amount in the ATP pool. The CK system stabilizes cellular [ATP] at approximately 3–6 mM, depending on the cell type, at the expense of [PCr], and thus maintains the intracellular ATP/ADP ratio at a very high level and consequently keeps the ∆G free energy change of ATP hydrolysis as high as possible. This guarantees an efficient use of ATP for all types of cellular functions; that is, the energy gained per ATP hydrolysed is kept at a physiological maximum. Resynthesis of ATP by the CK reaction, for example upon activation of muscle contraction, also removes ADP and H⁺ as products of ATP hydrolysis, so that the net product of ATPase plus the CK reaction is liberation of Pi as a metabolic signal. Thus, the CK acts not only acts as an energy buffer but also as a metabolic regulator (for review, see Wallimann et al. 1992, 2007).

CK isoforms and their molecular structure

CK, which is crucially involved in a plethora of bioenergetic processes, is particularly important and is expressed at high levels in cells with high energy requirements such as skeletal, cardiac and smooth muscle, kidney, brain and neuronal cells, retina photoreceptor cells, spermatozoa and sensory hair cells of the inner ear (Wallimann et al. 1992, 2007). The most important feature for the cellular functions of the CK/PCr system is the presence of tissue- and cell-specific CK isoforms with defined subcellular locations. All CK isoforms are encoded by separate nuclear genes and, in most tissues, a single cytosolic CK isoform is co-expressed together with a single mitochondrial CK isoform (mtCK). Cytosolic muscle-type CK (M-CK) and brain-type CK (B-CK) form homo–dimers or hetero-dimers, e.g. MM-CK in skeletal muscle, MM-, MB- and BB-CK in heart, or BB-CK in brain, kidney, spermatozoa, skin and many other tissues. MtCK is situated in the outer mitochondrial compartment and occurs as sarcomeric mtCK (smtCK) expressed mainly in muscle tissue and as ubiquitous mtCK (umtCK) expressed in a large number of other cells and tissues. Both form homo-dimers and homo-octamers, with the latter being the predominant oligomeric form in vivo.

Importantly, CK isoforms are localized differentially on a subcellular level and these specific locations are essential for the functioning of the CK network (Wallimann et al. 1992, 2007). As for many other cellular processes, “location, location is the name of the game” (Hurtley 2009). The proposed CK/PCr energy shuttle (Wallimann 1975; Saks et al. 1978; Bessman and Geiger 1981; Bessman 1986, 1987; Wallimann et al. 1992; Schlattner et al. 2006a, b; Wallimann et al. 2007) connects sites of ATP production (glycolysis and mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation) with subcellular sites of ATP utilization (ATPases). The molecular bases for this spatial energy buffering are functionally coupled, subcellular CK micro-compartments, at sites where ATP production and ATP consumption are tightly connected to CK/PCr action. At these subcellular sites, CK reactions may run in different (forward or backward) directions, but on the global cellular or organ level the CK system appears to be as if in equilibrium (see Fig. 1).

Fig. 1

The CK/PCr system for temporal and spatial energy buffering in cells of high and fluctuating energy requirements. Cr enters the target cells via Cr transporter (CRT). Inside the cell, PCr/Cr and ATP/ADP equilibria are adjusted by a soluble fraction of cytosolic CK isoforms (CK-c, see (3)). Another fraction of cytosolic CK (CK-g, see (2)) is specifically coupled to glycolytic enzymes (G), accepting glycolytic ATP, while mitochondrial CK isoforms (mtCK, see (1)) is coupled to adenine nucleotide translocator (ANT), thus accepting ATP exported from the matrix and generated by oxidative phosphorylation (OP). The contribution of both of these so-called microcompartments to total PCr generation depends on the cell type. The PCr thus generated is fed into the large PCr pool (up to 30 mM) that is available as a temporal or spatial energy buffer. Another fraction of cytosolic CK (CK-a, see (4)) specifically associated with subcellular sites of ATP utilization (ATPase, e.g. ATP-dependent or ATP-gated processes, ion-pumps etc.) also forms tightly coupled microcompartments regenerating the ATP utilized by the ATPase reaction in situ on the expense of PCr. The proposed CK/PCr energy shuttle or circuit connects, via highly diffusible PCr and Cr, subcellular sites of ATP production (glycolysis and mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation) with subcellular sites of ATP utilization (ATPases). This model is based on functionally coupled, subcellular CK microcompartments, where ATP production and ATP consumption are tightly connected to CK/PCr action (Wallimann 1975; Wallimann and Eppenberger 1985; Schlattner et al. 2006a; Wallimann et al. 2007)

The molecular structures of CK isoforms have been solved at atomic level (Fritz-Wolf et al. 1996; Rao et al. 1998; Eder et al. 1999, 2000a; reviewed by McLeish and Kenyon 2005) and their biochemical characteristics, e.g. enzyme catalysis, oligomerization, membrane interaction and binding to subcellular structures (e.g. Rossi et al. 1990; Eder et al. 2000b; Hornemann et al. 2000; Schlattner et al. 2000; Schlattner and Wallimann 2000; Schlattner et al. 2004) and specific interaction with subcellular partners and domains involved in such interactions (Kraft et al. 2000; Hornemann et al. 2003) have been studied in detail over the past decades. These studies have revealed important aspects of structure–function relationships and molecular physiology of CK that has allowed an understanding of the CK/PCr system and its eminent physiological role (Schlattner et al. 2006a; Wallimann et al. 2007).

Temporal and spatial energy buffering

Cr derived either from endogenous synthesis in the body or taken up from alimentary sources, e.g. meat and fish, is transported into muscle and other target cells with high and fluctuating energy requirements by a specific creatine transporter (CRT) (Speer et al. 2004; Straumann et al. 2006; see Fig. 1 with respective labels and numbering used in the following text). Imported Cr is charged to the high-energy compound PCr by the action of either strictly soluble, cytosolic CK (CK-c, (3)), by CK coupled to glycolysis (CK-g, (2)) or by mtCK coupled to oxidative phosphorylation (OP) (mtCK, (1)). In a resting cell, this results, at equilibrium, in a distribution of the total Cr pool into approximately two-thirds [PCr] and one-third [Cr] and in a very high ATP/ADP ratio (≥100:1). A fraction of cytosolic isoforms of CK are specifically associated with ATP-consuming processes (CK-a, (4)), such as the myofibrillar acto-myosin ATPase, the SR Ca²⁺-ATPase, the plasma membrane Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase, the ATP-gated K⁺-channel or ATP-requiring constituents for cell signalling.

Within these functional micro-compartments, CK regenerates the utilized ATP, drawing from the large PCr pool. These micro compartments with associated CK represent the ATP/PCr-consuming side of the CK/PCr system (4). At the ATP/PCr-generating side of the system, there are the glycogenolytic/glycolytic CK-g microcompartments (2) and the mtCK microcompartment connected to OP and energy channelling reactions inside the mitochondrion (1) (Schlattner et al. 2006b). MtCK is specifically located in the intermembrane space of mitochondria with preferential access to ATP generated by OP via adenine nucleotide translocator (ANT) of the mitochondrial inner membrane. This mitochondrial ATP is trans-phosphorylated into PCr that then leaves the mitochondria (Dolder et al. 2003). This route of ATP generation is most important for refilling the PCr energy store in oxidative tissues, e.g. upon extensive stimulation of muscle contraction and thus is relevant for recovery after exhausting exercise (Quistorff et al. 1993).

A large cytosolic PCr pool of up to 30 mM is built up by CK using ATP predominantly from OP (1) as in the heart, or from glycolysis (2) plus OP (1) as in skeletal muscle. PCr is then used to buffer global cytosolic (3) and local (4) ATP/ADP ratios. This would represent the temporal buffer function of the system. This function has been confirmed using reverse genetic approaches. For example, by introducing a phosphagen kinase gene, the CK orthologue arginine kinase (AK), into Escherichia coli or yeast, a phospho-arginine pool was built up that improved recovery of the bacteria and yeast from transient pH stress (Canonaco et al. 2002, 2003). By a similar strategy, yeast cells into which the genes for the enzymes for Cr biosynthesis (AGAT and GAMT) plus CK were introduced, proved to be resistant to metabolic stressors, such as low pH and starvation, by stabilizing the ATP levels during the transient stress period to pre-stress levels (Canonaco et al. 2002).

In cells that are polarized and/or have very high or localized ATP consumption (4), the differentially localized CK isoforms, together with easily diffusible PCr and Cr, maintain a high-energy PCr/Cr-circuit between ATP-providing (1, 2) and ATP-consuming processes (3, 4). Thus, the energy producing and consuming terminals of the shuttle are connected via PCr and Cr, with no obligatory need for ATP or ADP to diffuse, for example, from mitochondria (1) to the sites of ATPases (4) or backwards, respectively. Metabolite channelling (Schlattner et al. 2011) occurs where CK is associated with ATP-providing (1, 2) or ATP-consuming processes (4), that may be represented by ATPases, such as the actin-activated myosin MgATPase for muscle contraction (Wallimann et al. 1984; Ventura-Clapier et al. 1987; van Deursen et al. 1993) and actin-based cell motility (Kuiper et al. 2009), ATP-dependent ion-pumps and transporters, such as the SR Ca²⁺ pump (Rossi et al. 1990; de Groof et al. 2002), the Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase (Guerrero et al. 1997), the gastric H⁺/K⁺-ATPase (Sistermans et al. 1995b), as well ATP-gated ion-channels (Dzeja and Terzic 1998), ATP-requiring metabolic enzymes and protein kinases, such as AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) (Ceddia and Sweeney 2004) or Akt/PKB (Deldicque et al. 2007, 2008) involved in cell signalling (Saks et al. 2006b; Wallimann et al. 2007).

CK in specialized polarized and epithelial cells

CK is not only prominent in sarcomeric skeletal and cardiac muscle, where MM-CK is co-expressed with smtCK and where these isoforms are located at specific subcellular sites (Wegmann et al. 1992), but also in smooth muscle, brain and other non-muscle tissues where BB-CK is co-expressed with umtCK (Wallimann et al. 1992). For example, BB-CK is highly expressed in spermatozoa, retina photoreceptor cells (Wallimann and Hemmer 1994) as well as in the sensory hair cells present in the inner ear (Shin et al. 2007). The common denominator of these cells is that they are highly polar, elongated cells and that mitochondria are located at a distance from intracellular sites of ATP consumption. Therefore, these cells are the best models to investigate how mitochondrial-generated high-energy phosphates reach the sites of ATP consumption when separated by a long diffusion distance.

CK in spermatozoa

In sea urchin sperm, 100% of the energy required for sperm tail movement is generated in one single large mitochondrion located in the mid-piece behind the sperm head (Fig. 2). Mitochondria from sea urchins and other organisms harbour high concentrations of octameric mtCK (Wallimann et al. 1986a; Tombes and Shapiro 1987; Kaldis et al. 1996b), whereas the sperm tails contain a “cytosolic” CK which in sea urchins is a contiguous CK trimer (Quest et al. 1997), but in other organisms consists of brain-type BB-CK dimers (Wallimann et al. 1986a; Kaldis et al. 1996b). Most of the sperm tail CK is distributed along the entire sperm tail and/or associated with the cell membrane and the dynein ATPase (Quest et al. 1997).

Fig. 2

Spatial energy buffering by the CK/PCr: the PCr/Cr-shuttle in spermatozoa. Diffusion fluxes in sea urchin sperm were calculated from in vivo ³¹P-NMR saturation transfer NMR experiments (Kaldis et al. 1997). The diffusion flux of ADP from the sperm tail end towards the mitochondrion located at the mid piece is more than 2,000 times slower compared with that of Cr, whereas the diffusion flux of ATP from the region of the mitochondrion towards the sperm tail is roughly seven times slower than that of PCr. Thus, the PCr/Cr-shuttle is a physiological adaptation to overcome the diffusional limitations of adenosine nucleotides, especially of ADP, to facilitate long-distance energy transport, as well as high-throughput fluxes of cellular energy. A similar system has been proposed and proved to work also in the sensory hair cells of the inner ear (Shin et al. 2007) and in the polar photoreceptor cells of the retina (Wallimann et al. 1986b; Hemmer et al. 1993; Linton et al. 2010) and in the sensory hair cells of the inner ear (Shin et al. 2007). (Figure adapted from Kaldis et al. 1997)

In vivo experiments examining flagellar wave bending of living sea urchin sperm, which after activation were incubated with dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB), a specific inhibitor of CK, showed that increasing concentrations of DNFB attenuated firstly flagellar wave bending, and the amplitude of bending, at the very distal end of the sperm tail. As DNFB concentrations were increased, flagellar wave attenuation was gradually and progressively affected towards the more proximal regions and the mid-piece (Tombes et al. 1987). Similar results had been obtained with chicken sperm (Wallimann et al. 1986a). This was a first and very elegant visual demonstration showing that with progressive inhibition of CK, the diffusion distances for ATP from the mitochondrion to the very end of the sperm tail are indeed limited and that after inhibition of tail CK they are no longer compensated for by PCr/Cr diffusion.

Using in vivo ³¹P-NMR saturation transfer, high-energy phosphate concentrations as well as the rate of flux through the CK reaction were measured before and after activation of intact live sea urchin sperm in sea water (van Dorsten et al. 1996, 1997), combined with concomitant measurement of O₂ consumption (ATP production). Knowledge of the metabolite concentrations together with their diffusion constants then allowed the calculation of diffusion fluxes of the respective metabolites (Kaldis et al. 1997). As shown in Fig. 2, PCr and Cr display a significantly higher diffusion flux compared with ATP and ADP. Most remarkably, the diffusion flux of ADP from the distal sperm tail end back to the mid-piece mitochondrion is slower by three orders of magnitude compared with Cr (Kaldis et al. 1997). Thus, the CK/PCr shuttle is compensating for the diffusion limitations of mainly ADP and somewhat less so of ATP.

Functions of cytosolic CK associated with glycolysis

A fraction of cytosolic CK is associated with the glycolytic enzyme complex (Fig. 1, (2)) that, in sarcomeric muscle, is concentrated at the myofibrillar I-band (Kraft et al. 2000). It was shown that there, CK is specifically associated with those glycolytic enzymes that are either involved in ATP generation, such as pyruvate kinase (PK) (Dillon and Clark 1990; Kraft et al. 2000) or with the main regulatory enzyme of glycolysis, phosphofructokinase (PFK), which is regulated by rising [ATP] via a negative feed-back mechanism of ATP on PFK (Kraft et al. 2000). The CK-PFK interaction is pH-dependent and stronger at lower pH than at neutrality. This is physiologically relevant since under conditions of muscle activation and working glycolysis, the intracellular pH may drop. Thus, if glycolysis is initiated immediately after contraction to produce ATP, the close structural and functional association of CK with distinct members of the glycolytic micro-compartment makes sense in two ways: (a) glycolytic ATP is immediately removed from this compartment by associated CK and thus inhibition of glycolysis by negative feed-back regulation via ATP accumulation is prevented, and (b) glycolytic ATP can be used concomitantly to reduce the depletion of the PCr pool during contraction (Kraft et al. 2000; Wallimann et al. 2007). The principle of tight functional coupling of glycolysis to CK action has been shown in vitro in a system of reconstituted glycolysis containing CK (Scopes 1973) and also in vivo in an anoxic goldfish model (van den Thillart et al. 1989) where mitochondrial function is basically eliminated due to lack of oxygen. There, clearly, glycolytic ATP was shown to be used to replenish the PCr pool, although not to the maximal extent (van den Thillart et al. 1989; Van Waarde et al. 1990).

The coupling of CK to the glycogenolytic/glycolytic pathway is also supported by gated ³¹P-NMR measurements following at very high time-resolution the metabolite fluctuations elicited by single muscle contractions (Chung et al. 1998). After a single contraction the recovery of PCr is much faster than at the end of stimulation. This implies a distinct recovery mechanism in the first phase, which is in line with the contention that a significant proportion of glycogenolytic/glycolytic ATP is immediately used and trans-phosphorylated by CK to replenish PCr (see also Shulman 2005). After the end of stimulation, however, PCr recovery kinetics is consistent with a predominant role of OP (van den Thillart et al. 1989; Van Waarde et al. 1990; Quistorff et al. 1993; Chung et al. 1998). Finally, transgenic CK knock-out mice show an altered glycolytic network in their CK-deficient muscles (de Groof et al. 2001a), which also indicates an intricate interconnection of the two systems. This is corroborated by the fact that muscles of PFK-deficient patients show a dramatic delay in PCr recovery following exercise (Grehl et al. 1998).

Functions of mitochondrial CK (mtCK)

Metabolite channelling in the mtCK microcompartment

After the import of nuclear encoded, nascent mtCK through the mitochondrial outer membrane and cleavage of the N-terminal targeting sequence, mtCK first assembles into dimers. These dimers rapidly associate into octamers and although this reaction is reversible, octamer formation is strongly favoured by the high mtCK concentration in the inter-membrane space (Schlattner et al. 2006a). The symmetrical and cube-like mtCK octamers (Fritz-Wolf et al. 1996; Eder et al. 2000a) then directly bind to acidic phospholipids in the mitochondrial membranes (Fig. 3), preferentially to cardiolipin of the inner mitochondrial membrane (Schlattner et al. 2004), and in a calcium-dependent manner directly to VDAC (Schlattner et al. 2001). Affinity of both ANT and mtCK for cardiolipin situates them in common cardiolipin patches (Fig. 3), which can also be induced by membrane-bound mtCK (Epand et al. 2007b), thus allowing for a functional interaction between both proteins (Wallimann et al. 1998; Schlattner et al. 2006b). MtCK is found in two locations (Wegmann et al. 1991): (a) in the so-called mitochondrial contact sites (Fig. 3), where mtCK simultaneously binds to inner and outer membrane due to its symmetrical octameric structure (see below) and where it functionally associates with ANT and VDAC (Kottke et al. 1991) and (b) in the cristae (not shown) associated with inner membrane and ANT only (Wegmann et al. 1991; for details, see Schlattner et al. 2006a, 2011). A well-coupled MtCK micro compartment is also maintained by diffusion restrictions for adenylates at the outer membrane VDAC, possibly via direct interaction of VDAC with tubulin (Rostovtseva et al. 2008). The preferred or exclusive substrate and product fluxes in a well-coupled mtCK microcompartment are indicated in Fig. 3 by black arrows (Saks et al. 2000); minor or alternative fluxes at a lower degree of coupling are shown with blue arrows.

Fig. 3

Mitochondrial mtCK functions for high-energy metabolite channelling in mitochondria. In cells with oxidative metabolism, respiration (green arrow), ATP synthesis and ATP export through the inner mitochondrial membrane via adenine nucleotide transporter (ANT) are tightly coupled to trans-phosphorylation of ATP to PCr by mtCK and export of PCr into the cytosol by the outer membrane voltage-dependent anion channel (VDAC) as indicated by black arrows. In turn, Cr stimulates respiration by favoring constant supply of ADP to the matrix (black arrows), which also lowers ROS/RNS production in the intra-mitochondrial space (red arrows) and inhibits mitochondrial permeability transition. The tight coupling of substrate and product fluxes (black arrows) allows a so-called channeling of “high-energy” metabolites, with PCr being the one released into the cytosol, and ATP/ADP being mainly recycled within the mitochondria. The structural basis of these mtCK microcompartments are proteolipid complexes containing either VDAC, octameric mtCK and ANT in the peripheral intermembrane space (as shown) or octameric mtCK and ANT in the cristae (not shown). These proteolipid complexes are maintained by mtCK interactions with anionic phospholipids and VDAC in the outer membrane, and with cardiolipin and thus indirectly with cardiolipin-associated ANT in the inner membrane (see cardiolipoin patches). In cases of a less coupled mtCK microcompartment, e.g. after impairment of mtCK function by oxidative damage, there is partial direct ATP/ADP exchange with the cytosol (blue arrows). (Figure adapted from Kaldis et al. 1997; Meyer et al. 2006; Schlattner et al. 2006a; Schlattner et al. 2011) (The different fluxes are indicated by coloured arrows in the figure)

According to this scheme, ATP generated by OP via the F₀F₁-ATPase is transported through the inner membrane by ANT in exchange for ADP. This ATP may either leave the mitochondrion directly via outer membrane VDAC or is preferentially accepted and trans-phosphorylated into PCr by octameric mtCK in the intermembrane space. PCr then preferentially leaves the mitochondrion via VDAC and feeds into the large cytosolic PCr pool. ADP generated from the mtCK trans-phosphorylation reaction is accepted by ANT and immediately transported back into the matrix to be recharged. In contact sites, this substrate channelling allows for a constant supply of substrates and removal of products at the active sites of mtCK. In cristae, only ATP/ADP exchange is facilitated through direct channelling to the mtCK active site, while Cr and PCr have to diffuse along the cristae space to reach VDAC (not shown; for details, see Schlattner et al. 2006a, b; Wallimann et al. 2007).

Functional coupling of ANT to mtCK leads to a saturation of mtCK with ANT-delivered ATP, and at the same time to a locally high ATP/ADP ratio in the vicinity of mtCK. In combination with cytosolic Cr, entering the intermembrane space via VDAC, these conditions are favourable to drive the synthesis of PCr from ATP by mtCK without loss of energy content. This maintains maximal thermodynamic efficiency for high-energy phosphate synthesis and channelling, which in the form of PCr is exported into the cytosol (Dolder et al. 2003). Such a reaction sequence represents an instructive example of functional coupling and metabolite channelling. The active ATP/ADP exchange maintained by coupled mtCK favours ATP generation by the F₀F₁-ATPases and thus proper functioning of the respiratory chain, which could otherwise generate elevated levels of superoxide and reactive oxygen species (ROS) (Schlattner et al. 2011).

The intricate functional coupling of mtCK to the ANT (Vendelin et al. 2004), leading to a saturation of the ANT on the outer site of the inner membrane with ADP, which then is transported back into the matrix to be recharged by the F₀F₁-ATPase, efficiently couples substrate oxidation to ATP generation. Such tight coupling, by avoiding futile electron transfer, conceivably also would lower the production of free oxygen radicals (ROS). Indeed, mitochondrial respiration in the presence of Cr needs only micromolar concentrations of ADP to be fully stimulated, whereas in the absence of Cr comparably high concentration of ADP in the millimolar range are needed for a similar respiratory rate (Kay et al. 2000; Saks et al. 2000). This important phenomenon, termed “creatine-stimulated respiration” is entirely dependent on the presence of mtCK, for mitochondrial respiration can no longer be stimulated by Cr in intact chemically skinned muscle fibres or mitochondria isolated from cardiac or skeletal muscle of smtCK knockout mice (Kay et al. 2000). Finally, Cr exerts a strong indirect anti-oxidant effect by significantly reducing the intra-mitochondrial production of ROS, as well as elevating and preserving the mitochondrial membrane potential (Meyer et al. 2006). These Cr-meditated events may represent the basis for some of the remarkable neuro-protective effects of Cr that had been discovered recently (reviewed by Andres et al. 2008).

Control of mitochondrial permeability transition, stabilization of inner/outer mitochondrial membrane complex and anti-apoptotic effects of creatine

As mentioned earlier, mtCK occupies strategically important dual locations in the intermembrane and the cristae space (Kottke et al. 1991). In the periphery of the mitochondrion, mtCK is part of a protein complex that is involved in the so-called mitochondrial permeability transition (MPT) pore complex (O’Gorman et al. 1997a; Dolder et al. 2003). Although the molecular composition of the pore remains an open question, it seems to involve the adenine nucleotide transporter ANT-1 isoform and the voltage-dependent anion carrier VDAC (Zhivotovsky et al. 2009) together with mtCK (Kroemer et al. 2007). MPT represents an early event in apoptosis that often leads to swelling of mitochondria and release of apoptosis-inducing factors that can be initiated experimentally by exposure of mitochondria to atractyloside, an inhibitor of ANT, and/or by elevation of extra-mitochondrial [Ca²⁺] (Azzolin et al. 2010). Under these conditions, isolated mitochondria from the liver of normal wild-type mice, which do not express mtCK in the liver, undergo swelling and apoptosis. This process can be inhibited by cyclosporine, a potent anti-apoptotic drug. On the other hand, transgenic mice that have been engineered to express mtCK in their liver are protected from apoptosis and its destructive consequences by simple addition of Cr or its analogue cyclocreatine that is also phosphorylated by the CK reaction (Fig. 4). The extent of protection by Cr is comparable to that of cyclosporine (Dolder et al. 2003). Thus, Cr is not only involved in stimulating mitochondrial respiration but also works as an effective mitochondrial protectant and anti-apoptotic compound (Brdiczka et al. 2006). This may explain some of the cell-protective effects observed with Cr. For example, transgenic mice expressing mtCK in their liver acquire, after Cr supplementation, a remarkable tolerance against hypoxia (Miller et al. 1993) and liver toxins (Hatano et al. 1996), as well as against tumour necrosis factor-induced apoptosis (Hatano et al. 2004). Since PCr has been shown to bind to and protect biological membranes (Saks et al. 1996; Tokarska-Schlattner et al. 2003, 2005a), it is conceivable that the PCr generated by mtCK in the mitochondrial inter-membrane space would also bind to mitochondrial membranes and stabilize them against swelling, as this was shown for plasma membranes of erythrocytes (Tokarska-Schlattner et al. 2003, 2005a). Thus, mtCK plus Cr seem to exert cell protection not only by improving cellular energetics, but also by more or less energy-independent actions that also affect apoptosis (O’Gorman et al. 1997a; Brdiczka et al. 2006) (see Table 1).

Fig. 4

Mitochondrial permeability transition is inhibited by CK substrates. At a concentration of 10 mM, the CK substrates creatine (Cr) and cyclocreatine (cCr), Cr-analogon, inhibit MTP in isolated mouse liver mitochondria to a comparable degree as 1 μM cyclosporin A (CSA), the gold standard for MPT inhibition (Dolder et al. 2003). The Cr-analogon guanidinopropionic acid (GPA) that is not accepted as a substrate by the CK reaction has no effect as compared to control without additions (none). Isolated liver mitochondria from transgenic mice expressing uMtCK in their liver were analysed by a swelling (light scattering) assay. They were energized with glutamate/malate in presence of 2mM Mg²⁺ and then challenged by 120 μM Ca²⁺ where indicated. (Figure taken from Dolder et al. 2003 with permission)

Table 1

Pleiotropic effects of creatine for cell function and cell protection

Energy-related effects of creatineAnti-oxidant and anti-apoptotic effects of creatineOther effects of creatine

Cr improves cellular energy state (PCr/ATP ratio) and muscle performance	(Harris et al. 1992; Greenhaff et al. 1993)
Cr facilitates intracellular energy transport (PCr circuit or shuttle)	(Wallimann 1975; Saks et al. 1978, 2006b; Bessman and Geiger 1981; Wallimann and Eppenberger 1985; Bessman 1986; Wallimann et al. 1992, 1998; Kaasik et al. 2003; Wallimann et al. 2007)
Cr improves the efficiency of cellular energy utilization (e.g. for Ca2+-handling)	(Rossi et al. 1990; Steeghs et al. 1997; Pulido et al. 1998; van Leemputte et al. 1999)
Cr stimulates mitochondrial respiration (improved energy provision)	(Kay et al. 2000; Meyer et al. 2006)
Cr stabilizes mitochondrial PTP complex and thus acts as mitochondrial protectant (anti-apoptotic)	(O’Gorman et al. 1997a; Dolder et al. 2003; Hatano et al. 2004)
Cr acts as a mild direct anti-oxidant (free radical scavenger)	(Lawler et al. 2002)
Cr acts as a strong indirect anti-oxidant in mitochondria (where ROS production is lowered by tight coupling of respiration/ATP production to ATP export)	(Meyer et al. 2006; Sestili et al. 2006)
Cr reduces oxidative damage to DNA, specifically to mtDNA	(Guidi et al. 2008)
Cr up-regulates enzymes for oxidative stress defence	(Young et al. 2010)
Cr strongly protects in vivo from mitochondrial toxins (Rotenone & Paraquat)	(Hosamani et al. 2010)
Cr stabilizes mitochondrial PTP complex and thus acts as mitochondrial protectant (anti-apoptotic)	(O’Gorman et al. 1997a; Dolder et al. 2003; Hatano et al. 2004)
Cr induces differential expression of transcription factors and other genes	(Hespel et al. 2001; Louis et al. 2004; Deldicque et al. 2008; Safdar et al. 2008)
Cr reduces the appearance of inflammation markers during endurance exercise	(Santos et al. 2004; Bassit et al. 2008)
Cr activates cell signalling and enhances muscle cell differentiation	(Ceddia and Sweeney 2004; Louis et al. 2004; Deldicque et al. 2007, 2008)
Cr lowers homocysteine levels and lipid peroxidation (heart risk factors)	(Deminice et al. 2009)
Cr acts as an osmolyte, protecting cells against hypertonic stress	(Alfieri et al. 2006)
PCr binds to cell membranes and stabilizes and protects erythrocyte cell membranes	(Saks et al. 1996; Tokarska-Schlattner et al. 2003, 2005a)

Phenotypes of CK knockout mice point to important cellular functions of CK and the PCr/Cr system

Ablation of a given gene in transgenic knockout animals is a valuable tool to possibly evaluate the functions of this specific gene, or the respective protein coded by this gene, in an animal. The various constitutive CK knockouts, engineered by the Wieringa Group in Nijmegen NL, illustrates the phenotypical defects caused by the deletion of CK. Ablation of smtCK in muscle is a good example for a positive identification of a CK function. The fact that mtCK is required for stimulation of mitochondrial respiration by Cr (Saks et al. 2000) has been unambiguously corroborated by this technology with mtCK-deficient or double CK knockout mice (Kay et al. 2000).

Pleiotropic effects of creatine

Abrogation of CK enzymes in transgenic mice (see above) or depletion of the substrate Cr in Cr-analogue-fed (GPA) animals, respectively, both show muscle phenotypes with similar functional deficits (Mekhfi et al. 1990; Wyss and Wallimann 1994; O’Gorman et al. 1996, 1997b; Steeghs et al. 1997, 1998). The affected functions, such as the development of muscle force and muscle relaxation, including intracellular Ca²⁺ handling, can be enhanced in wild-type animals, as well as in humans, by Cr supplementation (Kraemer and Volek 1999; van Leemputte et al. 1999). These mostly energy-related ergogenic effects of Cr in sports, based on the seminal work by Harris and Greenhaff in the early nineties (Harris et al. 1992; Greenhaff et al. 1993), are well known and in the meantime widely accepted (Kamber et al. 1999). The same holds true for the effects of Cr for rehabilitation (Hespel et al. 2001; Johnston et al. 2009) (Table 1). However, a number of potentially beneficial effects of Cr, which are not directly related to enhancement of cellular energetics, have emerged, for example the protective effects of Cr on mitochondrial permeability transition pore opening (O’Gorman et al. 1997a; Dolder et al. 2003), an early event in apoptosis, or the antioxidant effects of Cr, as well as the interference of Cr with cell signalling affecting the expression of muscle transcriptional factors (Hespel et al. 2001; Hespel and Derave 2007; Deldicque et al. 2008) or activating important signalling pathways such a p38 Akt/PKB (Hespel et al. 2001; Deldicque et al. 2007; Hespel and Derave 2007; Deldicque et al. 2008) or AMPK (Ceddia and Sweeney 2004) (Table 1).

Such beneficial effects of Cr may also alleviate toxic drug effects that target bioenergetics and mitochondria, such as the anti-cancer drug doxorubicin (Tokarska-Schlattner et al. 2002, 2006). Doxorubicin accumulates in mitochondria and affects their functions including inhibition of CK isoforms (Tokarska-Schlattner et al. 2002; Tokarska-Schlattner et al. 2005b, 2007). In an animal study, Cr supplementation in combination with vitamins was able to increase survival of doxorubicin-treated rats (Santos et al. 2007).

The pleiotropic effects of Cr on muscle growth and muscle performance have been documented in more than 400 publications to date. Cr has a scientifically unambiguously proven record of being a truly ergogenic nutritional supplement that reaches the target organs, elevates muscle total Cr and PCr pools, leads to an increase in muscle mass and elevates muscle performance in a number of sports (for reviews, see the position stands of the International Society of Sports Nutrition: Buford et al. 2007; Kerksick et al. 2008). The effects of Cr are most beneficial for high-intensity intermittent exercise (Kraemer and Volek 1999) but positive effects of Cr have also been noted for better fatigue resistance (Rawson et al. 2011) and for improved recovery after heavy exercise (Yquel et al. 2002). It has also been realized that Cr could alleviate or spare muscle damage and inflammation caused by excessive endurance performance experienced in an ironman competition (Bassit et al. 2008; see also Table 1). It is important to note that the mostly anecdotal side effects of Cr supplementation that are reported, e.g. via internet can be dismissed on the basis of solid scientific evidence, even if Cr is taken for extended periods of time (i.e. years), (Kreider et al. 2003; Francaux and Poortmans 2006; Persky and Rawson 2007; Bender et al. 2008a). However, the most relevant issue with respect to potential side effects of Cr, namely the chemical purity of the Cr used, is definitely an issue (Pischel and Gastner 2007). Many of the pleiotropic effects of Cr for sports, health and disease are discussed in detail in this volume. Here, we would like to point out some potentially important new applications of Cr supplementation and their potential socio-economic implications for humans and for the global ecosystem.

Creatine supplementation for normal healthy people?

The protective effects of Cr as an adjuvant therapeutic intervention in disease states, such as neuromuscular, neuro-degenerative diseases, as well as muscle- and neuro-rehabilitation, have been recently reviewed in a special volume of “Subcellular Biochemistry” (“Creatine and Creatine Kinase in Health and Disease”, edited by G. Salomons and M. Wyss). In particular, the neuroprotective role of Cr that is relevant to a number of neuromuscular and neuro-degenerative diseases is well documented (Matthews et al. 1998; Klivenyi et al. 1999; Brewer and Wallimann 2000; Wyss and Kaddurah-Daouk 2000; Baker and Tarnopolsky 2003; Andres et al. 2005a, b; Brosnan and Brosnan 2007; Rodriguez et al. 2007; Tarnopolsky 2007; Adhihetty and Beal 2008; Andres et al. 2008; Valastro et al. 2009; Gualano et al. 2010).

Little has been mentioned so far of the potential benefits of Cr supplementation for normal healthy people. In a placebo-controlled, randomized animal study, it was shown in fact that life-long Cr supplementation, even at very high daily dosage, is of significant benefit to life expectancy and most importantly also for life quality of normal healthy mice (Bender et al. 2008a). In a recent study with human subjects, glucose tolerance in healthy sedentary males undergoing aerobic training was improved by Cr supplementation. Thus, a change in life-style together with intake of Cr may prevent or delay the onset of health problems, such as type-2 diabetes, obesity and metabolic syndrome (Gualano et al. 2008a).

Cr supplementation, in conjunction with exercise, was shown to improve muscle performance in elderly men and postmenopausal women (Gotshalk et al. 2002, 2008), as well as to increase bone mineral density in healthy elderly men (Chilibeck et al. 2005). This is in line with the findings that Cr increases survival, metabolic activity, as well as mineralization of cultured osteoblast cells in vitro (Gerber et al. 2005). Thus, Cr may not only be beneficial for muscle but also for bone health of normal healthy people. It is entirely conceivable that Cr supplementation could alleviate or prevent osteopenia and/or osteoporosis of postmenopausal women (Gerber et al. 2005, 2008), as Cr has been shown to stimulate collagen type I synthesis and secretion of osteoprotegerin in human bone cells derived from osteopenic subjects (Gerber et al. 2008).

Positive effects of Cr supplementation on memory, learning and mental performance (Rae et al. 2003), as well as on cognitive performance, have been demonstrated (McMorris et al. 2007), and a reduction of mental fatigue by Cr was also shown (Watanabe et al. 2002).

Creatine for the elderly?

A simple and inexpensive intervention, a daily supplementation with 2–5 g of chemically pure Cr for healthy adults and most importantly for senior and elderly people (Gotshalk et al. 2002, 2008), is likely to contribute as a preventive measure to muscle, bone and brain health, potentially saving billions of dollars otherwise spent for rehabilitation measures following accidents (Hespel and Derave 2007; Dalbo et al. 2009). Cr supplementation seems especially relevant for elderly, who often eat much less or no meat at all and thus likely have low tissue Cr levels, as limited data from vegans and vegetarians indicates (Burke et al. 2003; Watt et al. 2004). Recent nutritional recommendations by the US Society for Sarcopenia, Cachexia and Wasting Disease proposed Cr supplementation together with other measures for the management of sarcopenia (age-dependent progressive muscle loss) which is prevalent among the elderly (Morley et al. 2010). Interestingly, 2 weeks of 4 × 5 g of Cr daily improved cognitive performance in the elderly (McMorris et al. 2007). With respect to the possible beneficial effects of Cr supplementation that have been discussed for elderly (Dalbo et al. 2009), it is important to note that Cr acts as an osmolyte. Since Cr is taken up by the osmotically active sodium and chloride dependent CRT, concomitant import of NaCl into the target cells may lead to at least a temporary increase in the intracellular water content (Ziegenfuss et al. 1998). Hydration is an important physiological parameter in humans that gradually decreases with age (Aloia et al. 1998). However, in order to substantiate these preliminary results, many highly relevant to disease prevention and potentially with significant socio-economical health benefits, multi-centre epidemiological studies involving hundreds or thousands of subjects over prolonged periods of time would be necessary. Such studies would be expensive undertakings. However, as Cr promises only negligible financial returns to pharmaceutical companies, such studies would most likely have to be funded by government agencies.

Creatine as a prominent nutritional constituent for man since prehistoric times

Concerning possible health benefits for healthy people, a legitimate question that may be asked is whether modern man, due to greatly changed eating habits, is justified in supplementing the diet with additional Cr particularly when this can be synthesised endogenously and obtained through a balanced meat and fish diet. To possibly answer this question we need to examine early hominid nutrition. A recent archaeological survey in Ethiopia brought to light stone-tool inflicted cut and percussion marks on ungulate bones that were dated to older than 3.39 million years. These, the oldest findings of this kind, after careful microscopic examination were identified as being the result of early hominid stone tools used for removing flesh from bones and for retrieving bone marrow (McPherron et al. 2010). These findings indicate that Australopithecus afarensis already practised butchery of large animals and consumed meat some 3.4 million years ago.

Humans have clearly evolved as carnivores/omnivores, ingesting large quantities of meat and fish, and thus necessarily also Cr, as a significant part of their diet (Broadhurst et al. 1998; Richards 2002). There is evidence that evolutionarily human brain development and growth were strongly dependent on the availability of high-quality food, such as meat and/or fish, representing nutritionally rich sources of protein, fatty acids, vitamins and minerals (Milton 2003) and incidentally also of Cr. Evidence from isotopic analysis of skeletons of Neanderthals and modern Palaeolithic and Mesolithic humans highlights the importance of meat and fish in the hominid diet (Richards 2002). When successful at hunting or fishing, these hominids as true carnivores/omnivores, most likely devoured more than 1–2 kg of meat or fish per day during prolonged periods of time during the year, ingesting at least 5–10 g or more of Cr daily. The combination of high-quality diet and the higher proportion of maternal daily energy budget invested in the growing embryo during pregnancy of prehistoric women, would additionally have allowed for greater body weight as well as larger brain size (encephalization) relative to body weight of the infant at birth, compared with other primates (Ulijaszek 2002; Carlson and Kingston 2007). With respect to Cr, it is known that endogenous synthesis of Cr is energetically costly in terms of methyl-group equivalents. Carnivores/omnivores ingesting large amounts of Cr thus spare a significant proportion of the energy needed for acquisition of reactive methyl group equivalents in the form of S-adenosyl-l-methionine (AdoMet) that can be used for other anabolic synthetic pathways (Brosnan et al. 2007a, b).

It, therefore, seems that the evolutionary path of hominid development is tightly linked to food quality, e.g. to ingesting large amounts of meat and fish and concomitantly also of Cr. One might surmise from this that Cr supplementation should also belong to the nutritional requirements of modern man, depending on how much meat and/or fish is actually ingested daily. Depending on the cultural and economic background, the present daily meat consumption varies from zero (vegans) to approximately 150 g (Switzerland) or 250–300 g (USA, Australia) of meat/person/day (numbers include not only fresh but also processed meat that is known to contain much less Cr than fresh meat, or even none at all). These numbers correspond to a daily Cr consumption per person from zero to about 0.75–1.5 g and are clearly at the lower end of daily alimentary requirements for Cr that may be in the order of 2–4 g/person/day (see European Food Safety Authority web site: http://www.efsa.europa.eu/EFSA/efsa_locale-1178620753812_1178620761727.htm).

Finally, the fact that in most people who ingest extra Cr the total Cr pool size (Cr + PCr) in muscle is elevated by 5–20% indicates that in these the Cr pools are not saturated. This alone could be taken as an argument that even normal healthy people should supplement with Cr. The fact that meat consumption is recommended to be lowered globally for health (cf. high cholesterol, etc.) and ecological reasons lends additional support to the argument for Cr supplementation of the diet.

Foetal creatine metabolism and supply during pregnancy

Using a special precocial mouse strain, the spiny mouse (Acomys cahirinus) with a longer pregnancy than that of normal mice, closely resembling human pregnancy, it was convincingly shown that Cr supplementation protects the brain of the mouse pups in vivo against hypoxia and thus significantly enhances survival of the offspring (Ireland et al. 2008). This corroborates earlier findings that Cr protects the brain of newborn rats against hypoxia (Adcock et al. 2002) or of adult mice in a model of stroke (Prass et al. 2007). Also, Cr displayed astonishingly positive effects in traumatic brain injury in animals (Sullivan et al. 2000; Hausmann et al. 2002), as well as in children and adolescent patients (Sakellaris et al. 2006). Maternal Cr supplementation from mid-pregnancy onwards has most recently been shown to protect the diaphragm of the newborn spiny mouse from intra-partum hypoxia-induced damage (Cannata et al. 2010).

What is new in the spiny mouse study is the fact that pregnant dams were fed Cr. This orally fed Cr is actively transported into the foetus via placental CRT (Ireland et al. 2009). Cr supplementation of the pregnant dam leads to an enhancement of total Cr levels in most organs, not only of the mother but also of the embryo, including the brain and thus protects the precocial mouse pups from episodes of hypoxia during a simulated hypoxic birth (Ireland et al. 2008; Cannata et al. 2010). These are important findings indicating that Cr supplementation during pregnancy may be a general protective measure to lower the incidence of brain damage and enhance survival also of human babies that go through periods of anoxia during birth or are at high-risk for an ischemic/anoxic birth to start with. Thus, it is entirely conceivable that the protective effects of Cr that are observed with experimental animals will also hold true for humans.

In line with this hypothesis is the fact that endogenous Cr synthesis in the spiny mouse foetus gradually develops, but only reaches a mature level some time after birth (Ireland et al. 2009). The placenta expresses relatively high amounts of Cr transporter (CRT) and the expression of CRT in the placenta is high during the entire pregnancy and increases even more before birth (Ireland et al. 2009). This indicates that a significant part of embryonic Cr is taken up via the placenta and endogenous Cr synthesis in the foetus is not yet fully established. Thus, it can be concluded that the spiny mouse foetus depends on Cr delivered by the mother via her placenta. Although Cr is basically free of significant side effects, the dosage of Cr, used in the experiments with spiny mice described above, was very high with 5%, (w/w) in the food. This amounts, depending on how much food a pregnant mouse consumes, to an equivalent of 20–50 g of Cr or more per day for an adult human. This, on the other hand, demonstrates that Cr is safe also at high dosages, even for the foetus, which is in line with a study using Cr supplementation for premature babies in a clinical set-up, where no serious side effects of Cr had been observed in preterm babies (Bohnhorst et al. 2004).

In addition to the obvious benefits of Cr for the baby, Cr supplementation of the mother during pregnancy could additionally be of benefit for the build-up of a strong uterus during the third trimester, when the uterus energetically matures by implementing the CK system (Dawson and Wray 1985; Clark et al. 1993; Clark 1994; Wallimann and Hemmer 1994). This could help to ease birthing, which largely depends on the energy charge of uterine smooth muscle and thus also of the PCr pool size (Kumar et al. 1962), to develop sufficient muscle force for the expulsion of the embryo. Therefore, it may be legitimate to propose that Cr supplementation should be a standard regimen during pregnancy, as well as after birth, both for the pregnant and lactating mother, as well as for the baby. This would favour healthy brain development of the embryo and baby, as it is obvious that Cr-deficient patients suffer from severe developmental delay with accompanying mental retardation (Schulze 2003).

Creatine as natural constituent of mother’s milk

Human colostrums and milk contain significant concentrations of Cr, in the range of 0.2 mM (Hulsemann et al. 1987; Peral et al. 2005). The same is true for cow and sow milk with approximately 0.8 mM Cr (Sheffy et al. 1952; Hulsemann et al. 1987; Peral et al. 2005). Interestingly, in a detailed study on sow colostrums and milk throughout lactation and weaning, both Cr and PCr were identified at up to 1.5 and 1.2 mM concentrations, respectively (Kennaugh et al. 1997). It seems that Cr values can vary significantly, depending on the analytical techniques used. In addition, the variation found in the absolute Cr values and the Cr/Crn ratio may indicate that not always fresh milk was analysed. Using non-destructive NMR methods and spectral peak assignments, however, a prominent proton NMR peak was identified as Cr in bovine milk (Hu et al. 2004), thus leaving no doubt that Cr is a genuine chemical constituent in fresh milk. It would be of importance to investigate in detail whether and how nutrition would influence the total Cr content in mother’s milk.

A 3- to 4-month-old baby of 5 kg consumes approximately 800 ml milk per day from the mother at 0.2 mM Cr, or from cow milk, at 0.8 mM Cr (Hulsemann et al. 1987), amounting to a Cr ingestion of 4 or 16 mg Cr/kg body weight per day, respectively, which translates into approximately 0.3 or 1.2 g of Cr per day, respectively, for an adult person. Considering the fact that a significant amount of creatinine (25% in cow milk and more than 50% in human milk) was also found that may have arisen from Cr break-down during pasteurization of the milk, one can assume the above values to be lower-limit estimates, such that the actual Cr in fresh milk and, concomitantly, also the Cr intake by infants would be higher by a factor of 2–3 if really fresh milk were consumed.

Creatine supplementation of the mother during pregnancy, and of baby formulas and infant nutrition?

Cr is secreted by the mammary gland during lactation and has been shown to be absolutely required for normal brain development and brain function (see Wyss and Schulze 2002). According to recent data from rats, the rat mammary gland of dams does not synthesize the Cr to be secreted but is extracted from the circulation (Lamarre et al. 2010). Since there was no increase in endogenous Cr synthesis in the dams, this required an increase for the lactating mother of approximately 50% in alimentary Cr above the normal daily requirement. In rats, this is largely compensated by hyperphagia, as normal rat feed contains Cr that is introduced by dried meat and fish products (Lamarre et al. 2010). This suggests that pregnant, and even more so lactating mothers, who remain vegans or vegetarians during pregnancy and lactation, may suffer from an inadequate supply of Cr, which in turn may not be favourable for the development of the foetus and infant when nursing.

In the above work, it was further shown that while Cr is substantially accumulated in the growing pups, only 12% of this was obtained from the mother’s milk (Lamarre et al. 2010). Thus, the relatively high need for Cr in the rat pups clearly places a metabolic burden on them, since, as mentioned earlier, endogenous Cr synthesis is energy costly and may use as much as 40% of the total SAM available for trans-methylation reactions (Brosnan and Brosnan 2007; Brosnan et al. 2007a, b). If this is also true for humans (Mudd et al. 2007), the legitimate question arises, as to whether supplementing lactating women with Cr and thus have them secrete more Cr into their mothers milk may relieve some of the metabolic burden of energy-costly endogenous Cr synthesis by the baby. The same would hold true with respect to supplementing baby food and infant nutrition with Cr in non-nursing mothers or after weaning.

Except for soy-based baby milk, which is devoid of Cr, most of the baby formulas and follow-up baby nutrition preparations were found to contain Cr and Crn in a similar concentration range (0.3 and 0.1 mM, respectively) as mother’s milk, although with significant variations (Hulsemann et al. 1987). Thus, pending more thorough investigations, it may turn out to be advisable to control and eventually supplement not only purely vegetarian soy-based baby food, but also all infant nutrition products, with Cr. Interesting in this context is the fact that it was already noted in 1913 that “the increase in body weight of a baby after birth was roughly proportional to the Cr excreted in the urine by the respective mothers and that the excreted Cr/Crn ratio of the urine increased proportionally with mammary gland activity” (Mellanby 1913). Thus Cr, be it delivered via mothers milk or supplemented externally, seems generally beneficial for growth and development of the infant.

Since Cr is definitely an important constituent in milk of mammals, including humans, it is hard to understand that there still exist baby formulas and early infant nutrition products, especially products based entirely on soy-bean, which do not contain any or only very little Cr. Changing this situation should be a high priority of International and European Child Nutrition Advisory Boards, and this should be an important focus of Cr research during the coming years. The socio-economic benefit of this and other Cr supplementation applications, e.g. for general skeleto-muscular- (Tarnopolsky 2007) and neuro-rehabilitation (Sakellaris et al. 2006) seems obvious since every infant spared from irreversible brain damage caused for example by ischemia/anoxia during a difficult birth (Adcock et al. 2002; Ireland et al. 2008, 2009; Cannata et al. 2010) is beyond reckoning, not to speak of the relief from suffering. The objection that Cr could have side effects on human babies and infants has no scientific foundation. In a recent clinical study with premature infants, who were given 200 mg of Cr per kg body weight per day for 2 weeks, a dose corresponding to 14 g of Cr per day for an adult person of 70 kg, the treatment was well tolerated and no side effects were noted (Bohnhorst et al. 2004). However, there is an urgent need of clinically controlled studies in the field to determine a physiologically acceptable Cr dose for use with infants.

Children with a so-called Cr-deficiency syndrome, who have genetic defects either in one of the enzymes for endogenous Cr synthesis (AGAT or GAMT), or in the CRT, present with severe neurological symptoms, such as developmental and speech delay, mental retardation, autism and epilepsy (Schulze 2003), which is largely due to the complete absence of Cr in brain tissue. This emphasises the importance of Cr for normal brain development and function (Newmeyer et al. 2005) and, by implication, advocates the adoption of Cr supplementation for pregnant women, as well as for preterm babies and infants. It seems of utmost importance that Cr in infant food is recognized as an essential component of human nutrition and that its content in infant formulas should be mandatorily regulated and controlled.

Finally, the clinical tests (from urine and blood) for Cr-deficiency should be mandatory for all newborns. By this strategy, infants with treatable Cr-deficiencies (in AGAT or GAMT, but not in CRT) could be helped to lead a normal life.

Creatine supplementation of parenteral nutrition?

Individuals, who are supported in intensive care units (ICU), as well as severely ill patients with a variety of disease states, e.g. cancer patients with cachexia, fully depend on parenteral food which ideally should include supplementary Cr if needs are to be met. Unfortunately, Cr has not yet been recognized as a nutrient to be included in parenteral food. In this way, atrophy of muscles, particularly intra-costal muscles and diaphragm, could be lessened in IUC patients that are supported by artificial ventilation. The longer artificial ventilation is implemented, the more difficulties such patients experience in resuming independent breathing. Since Cr has been shown to significantly alleviate muscle disuse atrophy (Johnston et al. 2009), it is to be expected that resumption of breathing and rehabilitation of ICU patients may also be positively influenced by Cr. The same, of course, holds true for severely ill patients presenting with cachexia, as often occurs for cancer patients. Parenteral supplementation with Cr would help to prevent the physiological sequelae of Cr depletion to be expected in such patients (Wyss and Wallimann 1994).

Creatine for dialysis patients?

As pointed out earlier, Cr is not toxic to the kidney but rather is important for kidney function itself, since the CK/PCr system supports ion-pumps and metabolite transporters in this organ that are responsible for ion balance and resorption of metabolites from the urine. Patients with chronic renal failure (CRF) undergoing dialysis, who for obvious reasons are advised to restrict meat consumption, may present after a certain time with an altered skeletal and cardiac muscle energy metabolism, being low or deficient in Cr and showing a low PCr/ATP ratio (Pastoris et al. 1997; Tagami et al. 1998; Ogimoto et al. 2003). It is known that these patients lose muscle mass, become weaker and experience chronic fatigue. For these reasons, supplementation of dialysis patients with Cr might be viewed as an adjuvant therapy that should be implemented for counteracting some of the side effects of prolonged dialysis. An elegant method for Cr supplementation of this group of patients, undergoing either peritoneal or haemodialysis, would be to add appropriate amounts of Cr directly into the dialysis fluid. This would ease compliance and spare the patients to have to orally ingest yet another powder besides phosphate and calcium binders, etc. In the only study so with dialysis patients, involving the very limited number of five patients, oral Cr supplementation reduced spastic muscle cramps, a problem often observed in these patients (Chang et al. 2002).

Creatine as feed additive for animal nutrition, growing life stock and aquaculture?

Endogenous synthesis of Cr is energy-costly and consumes some 40% of the SAM available for methylation reactions (Brosnan et al. 2007a, b, 2009). In addition, the three amino acids needed for Cr synthesis, arginine, glycine and methionine are valuable and some are ‘physiologically’ expensive. By including chemically synthesised Cr in a pure form in animal feeds, these amino acids would be spared for protein synthesis and growth. This holds true also for processed and dry pet food, which compared with fresh meat and offal contains very little Cr (Harris et al. 1997), such that supplementation with Cr of pet food would make sense.

Chickens fed during a growing period of 41 days with an entirely vegetable soy-based feed, to which 0.2% w/w of pure Cr was added, show a 4% greater body weight gain compared with chickens fed with normal meat- and fish-meal containing feed. In addition, feed consumption in the Cr group decreased by 2–3% and the weight gain was shown to be due to growth of lean muscle mass (Pfirter and Wallimann, unpublished data). Thus, Cr may have significant potential as an additive for animal feed, replacing millions of tons of meat- and fish-meal for animals, as well as for fish aquaculture. On a global scale, this could help with problems of world hunger and the prevention of over-fishing of oceans for fish-meal production. Interestingly Cr supplementation of Drosophila melanogaster, known to express arginine kinase (AK) instead of CK (Wallimann and Eppenberger 1973), protects these flies from oxidative stress caused by exposure to rotenone, a potent mitochondrial toxin, and paraquat, a potent herbicidal redox cycler, that both generate ROS (Hosamani et al. 2010). Since these insects are not able to phosphorylate Cr into PCr, the protective effects of Cr observed cannot be due to improved cellular energetics, but are more likely related to anti-oxidant and/or anti-apoptotic effects of this guanidino compound. Thus Cr may be added to animal feed as a protectant also against environmental oxidative and toxic stress.