Flavonoid metabolites reduce tumor necrosis factor‐α secretion to a greater extent than their precursor compounds in human THP‐1 monocytes
Abstract
1Scope
Flavonoids are generally studied in vitro, in isolation, and as unmetabolized precursor structures. However, in the habitual diet, multiple flavonoids are consumed together and found present in the circulation as complex mixtures of metabolites. Using a unique study design, we investigated the potential for singular or additive anti‐inflammatory effects of flavonoid metabolites relative to their precursor structures.
2Methods and results
Six flavonoids, 14 flavonoid metabolites, and 29 combinations of flavonoids and their metabolites (0.1–10 μM) were screened for their ability to reduce LPS‐induced tumor necrosis factor‐α (TNF‐α) secretion in THP‐1 monocytes. One micromolar peonidin‐3‐glucoside, cyanidin‐3‐glucoside, and the metabolites isovanillic acid (IVA), IVA‐glucuronide, vanillic acid‐glucuronide, protocatechuic acid‐3‐sulfate, and benzoic acid‐sulfate significantly reduced TNF‐α secretion when in isolation, while there was no effect on TNF‐α mRNA expression. Four combinations of metabolites that included 4‐hydroxybenzoic acid (4HBA) and/or protocatechuic acid also significantly reduced TNF‐α secretion to a greater extent than the precursors or metabolites alone. The effects on LPS‐induced IL‐1β and IL‐10 secretion and mRNA expression were also examined. 4HBA significantly reduced IL‐1β secretion but none of the flavonoids or metabolites significantly modified IL‐10 secretion.
3Conclusion
This study provides novel evidence suggesting flavonoid bioactivity results from cumulative or additive effects of circulating metabolites.
Abbreviations
1Introduction
Flavonoids are phenolic secondary plant metabolites found ubiquitously in our habitual diets 1, 2. They have been extensively studied due to the widely held hypothesis that they contribute to the positive health effects associated with fruit and vegetable consumption 3. Flavonoid consumption has been associated with a lower incidence of chronic age related diseases, including cardiovascular disease, cancer, and neurodegenerative disorders 3, 4, 5, where chronic low grade inflammation is a central underlying predisposing risk factor 6. Tumor necrosis factor‐alpha (TNF‐α) and IL‐1β are central mediators of the inflammatory process and pharmacological inhibition of these pro‐inflammatory cytokines results in improved cardiovascular health and a lower incidence of myocardial infarction 7, 8. Flavonoids have been shown to reduce TNF‐α and IL‐1β levels in human and animal studies and cell culture models 9, 10, 11. In addition, IL‐10 plays an important anti‐inflammatory role in the resolution of inflammation and has been shown to be upregulated by several flavonoids including hesperidin, quercetin, and catechin 12, 13. TNF‐α, IL‐1β, and IL‐10 are all regulated by the pro‐inflammatory transcription factor nuclear factor kappa‐light‐chain‐enhancer of activated B cells (NF‐κB), and NF‐κB has also been shown to be a target of several flavonoids including quercetin 14 and cyanidin‐3‐glucoside (C3G) 15.
Most in vitro studies conducted to date have focused on the effect of individual precursor flavonoids on inflammatory mediators 16. However, flavonoids are extensively metabolized and found in the systemic circulation as phase II conjugates or products of bacterial catabolism 17, 18. It is therefore more relevant to study the effects of flavonoid metabolites (Fig. 1) over their precursor unmetabolized structures 19. Similarly, previous studies have focused on supraphysiological concentrations of flavonoids in in vitro studies using doses often between 25 and 100 μM 16. Therefore, it is equally important to consider physiologically appropriate concentrations of flavonoid metabolites, as most are unlikely to reach levels in excess of 10 μM in the human systemic circulation 20. Lastly, in the habitual diet, flavonoids are consumed as complex mixtures of compounds, which are consequently present in the systemic circulation as diverse mixtures of precursor and metabolic conjugates. It is therefore important to consider the potential for additive, synergistic, or inhibitory effects of multiple compounds collectively. Here, we have designed a study to address these previous conceptual inaccuracies and attempted to explore the activities of flavonoid metabolites at physiologically relevant concentrations and in complex mixtures as they may be found in vivo.
In the present study, human THP‐1 monocytic cells were utilized (as previously described 21) as an in vitro screening model of inflammation, to explore the activity of flavonoid metabolites on LPS‐induced TNF‐α, IL‐1β, and IL‐10 expression. Here, six common dietary flavonoids (quercetin, naringenin, epicatechin, hesperetin, peonidin‐3‐glucoside (P3G), C3G), 14 metabolites (including synthesized methyl, glucuronide, and sulfate conjugates), and 29 unique combinations of flavonoid and metabolite were investigated. The treatments were explored across concentrations ranging from 0.1 to 10 μM (Table 1) in order to investigate the effects of more physiologically relevant concentrations of flavonoids and their metabolites 17, 19, 22, 23, as would be potentially found in the circulation following the consumption of a flavonoid‐rich diet.
Constituent components of the 29 treatment combinationsa
| Precursor flavonoids | Flavonoid metabolites | ||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Combination | Naringenin | C3G | Quercetin | Epicatechin | P3G | Hesperetin | PCA | VA | 4HBA | BA‐glucuronide | BA‐sulfate | PCA‐3‐glucuronide | PCA‐4‐glucuronide | PCA‐3‐sulfate | PCA‐4‐sulfate | VA‐glucuronide | VA‐sulfate | IVA‐glucuronide | IVA‐sulfate |
| 1 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 2 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 3 | + | + | + | ||||||||||||||||
| 4 | + | + | + | + | |||||||||||||||
| 5 | + | + | + | + | |||||||||||||||
| 6 | + | + | + | + | + | ||||||||||||||
| 7 | + | + | + | + | + | + | |||||||||||||
| 8 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 9 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 10 | + | + | + | ||||||||||||||||
| 11 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 12 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 13 | + | + | + | ||||||||||||||||
| 14 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 15 | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | ||||||
| 16 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 17 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 18 | + | + | + | ||||||||||||||||
| 19 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 20 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 21 | + | + | + | ||||||||||||||||
| 22 | + | + | + | + | + | ||||||||||||||
| 23 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 24 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 25 | + | + | + | ||||||||||||||||
| 26 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 27 | + | + | |||||||||||||||||
| 28 | + | + | + | ||||||||||||||||
| 29 | + | + | + | + | + | ||||||||||||||
aThe concentrations used represent cumulative concentrations, e.g. a 10 μM dose consisting three analytes contains 3.33 μM of each analyte.
2Materials and methods
2.1Chemicals
The flavonoids hesperetin, naringenin, quercetin, epicatechin, C3G, and metabolites protocatechuic acid (PCA), isovanillic acid (IVA), vanillic acid (VA), and 4‐hydroxybenzoic acid (4HBA) were obtained from Sigma Aldrich (Poole, UK). P3G was obtained from Polyphenols Laboratories AS (Sandes, Norway). The remaining metabolites (benzoic acid (BA)‐glucuronide, BA‐sulfate, PCA‐3‐glucuronide, PCA‐4‐glucuronide, PCA‐3‐sulfate, PCA‐4‐sulfate, IVA‐glucuronide, IVA‐sulfate, VA‐glucuronide, and VA‐sulfate) were not commercially available and synthesized for the present study, as previously described 24. Flavonoids and their metabolites were dissolved in DMSO and added to the cells at a final concentration of 0.1% DMSO. Treatments containing mixtures of flavonoids or metabolites represented cumulative concentrations of 0.1, 1, 10, or 100 μM, where each component provided an equal molar concentration. For example, a 0.1 μM treatment combination comprising three components contained 0.033 μM of each component, or 0.33 μM of each component for a 1 μM treatment, or 3.3 μM of each component for a 10 μM, and similarly 33.3 μM for the 100 μM treatment. Escherichia coli LPS 5 mg/mL (O111:B4) was obtained from Calbiochem (San Diego, USA). SB203580 was obtained from Tocris Bioscience (Bristol, UK). DMSO and all other reagents were from Sigma, unless otherwise indicated.
2.2Cell culture
The human monocytic cell line, THP‐1, was obtained from the European Collection of Cell Cultures (Health Protection Agency, Salisbury, UK) and cultured in RPMI 1640 medium (PAA Laboratories, Pasching, Austria), supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum (Sigma), 2 mM l‐glutamine, 100 U/mL penicillin, and 100 μg/mL streptomycin (PAA Laboratories) as previously described 25. Cells were maintained in culture at 37°C in a humidified atmosphere with 5% CO2. Cell density was maintained between 0.3 and 0.8 × 106 cells/mL and used between passages 5 and 20.
2.3Cell viability assay
Cell viability was measured using the WST‐1 assay according to the manufacturer's protocol (Roche Diagnostics, Mannheim, Germany). Briefly, 0.5 × 105 cells/well were seeded in 96‐well plates. Treatments were added at final concentrations of 5, 10, 50, and 100 μM. Cells were incubated for 24 h at 37°C and 5% CO2. A total of 10 μL WST‐1 Cell Proliferation Reagent was added for 3 h and absorbance was measured at 450 nm.
2.4Cytokine protein secretion
THP‐1 cells (0.5 × 106 cells/well) were seeded in 24‐well plates. Treatments were added at final concentrations of 0.1, 1, 10, and 100 μM. Plates were incubated at 37°C, 5% CO2 for 30 min prior to addition of LPS. For TNF‐α production, cells were stimulated with LPS (100 pg/mL) for 3 h. Cells were stimulated with 1 μg/mL LPS for 24 h for IL‐1β and IL‐10 production assays. Cytokine concentrations in supernatants were quantified using human ELISA kits from BD Biosciences (Oxford, UK). ELISAs were carried out in accordance to the manufacturer's instructions. Briefly, 100 μL of supernatant sample or standard in duplicate was incubated for 2 h at room temperature on 96‐well plates precoated with an appropriate anti‐human monoclonal antibody. Following incubation, plates were washed in PBS/0.05% Tween‐20. Immediately following washing, 100 μL of enzyme‐linked secondary antibody was added to each well and incubated for 1 h at room temperature. Plates were washed, 100 μL of substrate solution was added to each well, and incubated for 30 min, followed by the addition of 50 μL 1M H2SO4. Absorbance was determined at 450 nm. The interassay coefficients of variation were 9.9, 7.8, and 5.7% for the TNF‐α, IL‐1β, and IL‐10 ELISAs, respectively.
2.5Cytokine mRNA expression
THP‐1 cells (1 × 106 cells/mL) were treated with 1 μM compounds for 30 min prior to stimulation with LPS. After incubation with 100 pg/mL LPS for 2 h (TNF‐α) or 1 μg/mL LPS for 24 h (IL‐1β), cells were centrifuged and the pellet was resuspended in TRIzol Reagent (Ambion, Carlsbad, USA) and total RNA was extracted according to the manufacturer's instructions. RNA concentration was quantified using a Nanodrop ND‐1000 spectrophotometer and concentrations were adjusted to 200 ng/μL. RNA was reverse transcribed using a TaqMan kit (Roche Diagnostics) according to the manufacturer's instructions. Reverse transcription was carried out on a PTC‐100 thermocycler (Bio‐Rad, Herts, UK) using the following conditions: 21°C for 10 min, 42°C for 15 min, 99°C for 5 min, and 4°C for 5 min. Primers were obtained from Invitrogen (Paisley, UK) with the following sequences: TNF‐α forward: 5′‐GCCCAGGCAGTCAGATCATC5‐3′, reverse: 5′‐CGGTTCAGCCACTGGAGCT‐3′; IL‐1β forward: 5′‐GGACAAGCTGAGGAAGATGC‐3′, reverse: 5′‐TCGTTA TCCCATGTGTCGAA‐3′, and GAPDH forward: 5′‐AACA GCCTCAAGATCATCAGCA‐3′, reverse: 5′‐TGCTAAGCAGTTGGTGGTGC‐3′. mRNA expression was measured by real‐time PCR using a QIAGEN Rotor‐Gene Q and SYBR Green technology. DNA was replicated for 1 cycle of 95°C for 120 s, and then 40 cycles of 95°C for 15 s and 40°C for 40 s. Each mRNA expression was normalized against GAPDH mRNA expression using the standard curve method.
2.6NF‐κB luciferase reporter assay
NF‐κB pGL3 firefly luciferase and pGL4.73 Renilla luciferase plasmids and the Dual‐Glo Luciferase assay were purchased from Promega (Madison, USA). One milliliter of THP‐1 cells at 1 × 106 cells/mL were seeded in 24‐well plates in RPMI 1640 medium. After 24 h, cells were transfected using Lipofectamine LTX Plus reagent and Opti‐MEM reduced serum media (Invitrogen) according to the manufacturer's protocol and as previously described 26. Cells were transfected with pGL4.73 or pGL3 for 18 h. Cells were treated with 10 μM compounds for 30 min prior to LPS stimulation (100 ng/mL) for 7 h at 37°C, 5% CO2. Reporter activity was measured using the Dual‐Glo luciferase assay on a BMG Labtech POLARstar OPTIMA plate reader. Each firefly reading was normalized to the corresponding Renilla reading prior to analysis.
2.7Statistics
Data are presented as mean ± SD, from three independent biological replicates. Treatments were compared to 0.1% DMSO vehicle control (VC). One‐way ANOVA with post‐hoc LSD (when comparing more than two conditions), or a two‐tailed independent sample t‐test (when comparing two conditions) was performed using PASW statistics 18 software (Chicago, USA); *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001.
3Results
3.1Effects of flavonoids and their metabolites on cell viability
Flavonoids have previously been reported to affect cell viability at high concentrations 27. To ensure that the effects of the treatments in the present study were not influenced by cell viability, THP‐1 cells were treated with 5–100 μM flavonoid for 24 h and cell viability was measured by WST‐1 assay. No flavonoid or metabolite was found to affect cell viability, individually or in combination, at 5, 10, or 50 μM (data not shown). Quercetin and naringenin were the only compounds to significantly reduce cell viability at 100 μM (16.2 ± 7.6%, p < 0.001 and 13.2 ± 10.7%, p < 0.001; respectively).
3.2Flavonoid metabolites inhibit TNF‐α secretion
Of the 20 individual compounds and 29 combination treatments screened, two flavonoids, five metabolites, and four combinations significantly reduced LPS‐induced TNF‐α protein levels compared to VC (Table 2). Specifically, treatment with the precursor flavonoids C3G and P3G (reduction 13–20%; p ≤ 0.050), and the metabolites BA‐sulfate, IVA, IVA‐glucuronide, VA‐glucuronide, and PCA‐3‐sulfate (reduction 27–41%; p ≤ 0.040), significantly reduced LPS‐induced TNF‐α secretion. Of the combination treatments tested, treatments containing PCA and 4HBA (combination 9); PCA, VA, and 4HBA (combination 10); 4HBA, BA‐glucuronide, and BA‐sulfate (combination 13); and PCA and PCA‐3‐glucuronide (combination 16) significantly reduced TNF‐α secretion (reduction of 4–47%; p ≤ 0.050). The individual constituents of the active combination treatments were also assessed and did not significantly reduce TNF‐α compared to the VC at any concentration tested, up to and including 100 μM (Fig. 2).
| Treatment | Average change in TNF‐α protein from VC (% ± SD) | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.1 μM | 1 μM | 10 μM | |
| C3G | ↓ 9.5 ± 2.4 | ↓ 13.7 ± 4.4* | ↓ 12.2 ± 1.2 |
| P3G | ↓ 12.7 ± 4.2* | ↓ 19.8 ± 3.1*** | ↓ 13.4 ± 6.5* |
| IVA | ↓ 12.8 ± 3.3 | ↓ 27.0 ± 3.5* | ↓ 20.2 ± 5.7 |
| BA‐sulfate | ↓ 24.9 ± 32.5 | ↓ 37.2 ± 40.1* | ↓ 27.3 ± 38.5 |
| PCA‐3‐sulfate | ↓ 24.6 ± 33.8 | ↓ 41.1 ± 42.0* | ↓ 38.6 ± 43.0* |
| IVA‐glucuronide | ↓ 16.8 ± 15.1* | ↓ 32.8 ± 9.8*** | ↓ 33.3 ± 11.8*** |
| VA‐glucuronide | ↓ 12.5 ± 15.7 | ↓ 26.9 ± 19.4* | ↓ 26.8 ± 4.9* |
| Combination 9 | ↓ 26.3 ± 6.4* | ↓ 33.1 ± 6.1** | ↓ 42.7 ± 13.5*** |
| Combination 10 | ↓ 17.9 ± 9.8 | ↓ 47.4 ± 12.3** | ↓ 35.1 ± 5.1** |
| Combination 13 | ↓ 10.3 ± 29.0 | ↓ 26.2 ± 37.6 | ↓ 32.0 ± 35.4* |
| Combination 16 | ↓ 1.1 ± 19.0 | ↓ 6.5 ± 21.1* | ↓ 4.4 ± 13.4* |
Treatments (see Table 1 for details) were added to THP‐1 cells at final concentrations of 0.1, 1, and 10 μM for 30 min prior to stimulation with 100 pg/mL LPS for 3 h. LPS‐induced TNF‐α protein secretion was quantified by ELISA. Data shown are averages of three independent experiments, each carried out in technical duplicate. Analysis was performed by one‐way ANOVA and post‐hoc LSD, *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p ≤ 0.001.
Effect of flavonoid treatments on LPS‐induced THP‐1 TNF‐α protein secretion. (A) C3G, (B) P3G, (C) IVA, (D) BA‐sulfate, (E) PCA‐3‐sulfate, (F) IVA‐glucuronide, (G) VA‐glucuronide, (H) Combination 9, (I) Combination 10, (J) Combination 13, (K) Combination 16, (L) PCA, (M) 4HBA, (N) VA, (O) BA‐glucuronide, and (P) PCA‐3‐glucuronide. Data were normalized to an LPS control and then compared to VC. Columns represent mean ± SD (n = 3). Each independent experiment was carried out in technical duplicate. *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001 (one‐way ANOVA and post‐hoc LSD).
3.3Effects of flavonoids on LPS‐induced NF‐κB‐driven gene transcription
Flavonoids have previously been reported to inhibit NF‐κB 28, 29, which is a major regulator of TNF‐α. To determine if the flavonoids or metabolites also reduced other NF‐κB‐regulated cytokines, the bioactive treatments identified in the TNF‐α screen were investigated for effects on IL‐1β and IL‐10 secretion. Here, none of the active treatments significantly inhibited LPS‐induced IL‐1β secretion (Table 3). Interestingly, 4HBA, a component of combination 9 and 10, significantly reduced IL‐1β protein secretion (49.6 ± 12.3% versus VC, p = 0.011). None of the active treatments modified IL‐10 secretion (p ranging from 0.479 to 0.948, data not shown). These results indicate that the bioactive effects of the individual treatments and combinations are largely selective for TNF‐α and are therefore independent of NF‐κB. To verify this, an NF‐κB luciferase assay was utilized. In cells transfected with an NF‐κB reporter and stimulated with a subset of individual treatments or their combinations for 30 min prior to LPS stimulation, none of the individual treatments or combinations had any effect on LPS‐induced NF‐κB reporter activity (p ranging from 0.144 to 0.822, data not shown), confirming that the effects on TNF‐α are independent of NF‐κB.
| Treatment | Average change in IL‐1β protein from vehicle control (% ± SD) |
|---|---|
| 1 μM | |
| C3G | ↓ 1.3 ± 28.9 |
| P3G | ↓ 15.2 ± 20.6 |
| IVA | ↑ 19.2 ± 10.2 |
| IVA‐glucuronide | ↑ 24.3 ± 15.3 |
| VA‐glucuronide | ↓ 1.7 ± 50.3 |
| PCA‐3‐sulfate | ↓ 31.2 ± 3.6 |
| BA‐sulfate | ↓ 28.9 ± 35.0 |
| Combo 9 | ↓ 8.7 ± 17.8 |
| Combo 10 | ↑ 15.5 ± 30.9 |
| Combo 13 | ↓ 6.0 ± 11.7 |
| Combo 16 | ↓ 10.3 ± 22.3 |
| VA | ↓ 23.0 ± 44.4 |
| PCA | ↓ 16.8 ± 15.0 |
| 4HBA | ↓ 49.6 ± 12.3* |
| BA‐glucuronide | ↓ 2.6 ± 10.5 |
| PCA‐3‐glucuronide | ↓ 2.0 ± 22.1 |
Treatments were added to THP‐1 cells at a final concentration of 1 μM for 30 min prior to stimulation with 10 μg/mL LPS for 24 h. Data were normalized to LPS and compared with VC. Data shown are averages of three independent experiments, each carried out in technical duplicate. Analysis was performed by two‐tailed independent samples t‐test, *p < 0.05.
3.4Post‐transcriptional effects of flavonoids on cytokine secretion
To determine if the effects of the bioactive treatments on LPS‐induced TNF‐α were transcriptional or post‐transcriptional, cells were treated with the active treatments and TNF‐α mRNA expression was examined by RT‐qPCR. None of the bioactive treatments significantly inhibited LPS‐induced TNF‐α mRNA expression (Table 4). Indeed, one of the compounds of combination 13, BA‐glucuronide, significantly (p = 0.050) increased TNF‐α mRNA expression. In addition, 4HBA, which significantly inhibited LPS‐induced IL‐1β secretion (p = 0.001), had no effect on IL‐1β mRNA expression (p = 1.000).
| Treatment | Average change in TNF‐α mRNA from vehicle control (% ± SD) |
|---|---|
| 1 μM | |
| C3G | ↑ 0.8 ± 13.0 |
| P3G | ↓ 7.0 ± 28.7 |
| IVA | ↓ 2.8 ± 62.7 |
| IVA‐glucuronide | ↑ 17.1 ± 51.8 |
| VA‐glucuronide | ↑ 6.3 ± 27.1 |
| PCA‐3‐sulfate | ↓ 1.3 ± 21.7 |
| BA‐sulfate | ↓ 8.8 ± 33.2 |
| Combo 9 | ↑ 17.7 ± 36.0 |
| Combo 10 | ↑ 9.5 ± 28.7 |
| Combo 13 | ↓ 35.9 ± 65.8 |
| Combo 16 | ↑ 3.6 ± 56.1 |
| VA | ↑ 20.2 ± 55.5 |
| PCA | ↑ 17.5 ± 36.0 |
| 4HBA | ↑ 44.5 ± 64.6 |
| BA‐glucuronide | ↑ 23.8 ± 6.5* |
| PCA‐3‐glucuronide | ↑ 25.9 ± 77.7 |
Treatments were added to THP‐1 cells at a final concentration of 1 μM for 30 min prior to stimulation with 100 pg/mL LPS for 2 h. Data were normalized to GAPDH and compared with VC. Data shown are averages of three independent experiments, each carried out in technical duplicate. Analysis was performed by two‐tailed independent samples t‐test.
4Discussion
Flavonoids are perceived to be key components responsible for the observed health effects of fruits and vegetables 30. However, concentrations of individual flavonoid species in the circulation, after “normal/habitual” dietary consumption, are generally extremely low; many orders of magnitude below those observed to elicit cellular activity in in vitro studies 19. We hypothesized that the reported biological activities of flavonoids, following consumption, are not a direct consequence of any individual flavonoid working in isolation, but result from a yet uncharacterized cumulative activity of metabolites, working in combination. We therefore established a screening model to test this hypothesis, examining structurally similar flavonoids and some of their shared metabolites in isolation, and in combinations, as would potentially occur following dietary exposure. Here, we observed some metabolites were more bioactive than their precursor structures and that some combinations of metabolites were more bioactive than their constituent compounds.
The dietary flavonoids utilized in the present investigation are found in abundance in our diets (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/193804/familyfood‐2011report.pdf). Food sources include onions and tea (quercetin), citrus (naringenin and hesperetin), cocoa/chocolate, red wine and green tea (epicatechin), and red and purple berries (peonidin and cyanidin) 31, 32. Reported levels of consumption vary considerably, and depend on country and population/cohort studied. In cohorts from the United States, Netherlands, and Spain, dietary consumption has been estimated between 158 and 313 mg/day; representing levels for flavan‐3‐ols between 32 and 158 mg/day, flavanones between 14 and 50 mg/day, flavonols between 13 and 21 mg/day, and anthocyanins between 3 and 18 mg/day. However, these estimates represent average consumption, and for many flavonoids considerably higher dietary levels can be achieved from a single serving of a flavonoid‐rich food. For example, anthocyanin concentrations in berries reach 100–700 mg/100 g and it is therefore not unrealistic to consume as much as 250 mg in a single serving 33, 34, 35. Despite potentially high dietary intakes, levels of flavonoids in the blood, postconsumption, are relatively low (generally well below 10 μM 16). Rather than concentrating on dietary flavonoids, the present study focused on the bioactivity of the more physiologically relevant flavonoid metabolites, as phenolic metabolites are reported to be the predominant compounds in the systemic circulation 17, 19, 32, 36. As there is a substantial diversity of phenolic metabolites (or ring‐fission products) reported for the various flavonoids 17, 32, we focused on phenolic acid conjugates common to many flavonoid species, in addition to being found in the habitual diet themselves. These include conjugates of PCA, VA, and BA, which have been reported as phenolic metabolites of berry anthocyanins 17, 19, cocoa flavan‐3‐ols 22, 23, and reported in our recent study of citrus flavanones 37. In addition, phenolic metabolites such as VA and ferulic acid are found in the diet in grain and beer 38, while BA conjugates can be derived from caffeic acid and ferulic acid, which are found in red wine or derived from hydrolysable tannins in the diet 32.
In the current study, we explored bioactivity across a concentration range of 0.1–10 μM, as it represents the relative serum/plasma concentration of flavonoids and their phenolic metabolites reported in the literature. Serum/plasma concentrations of unmetabolized precursor flavonoids are generally quite low, and reported in low to high nanomolar concentrations (10–200 nM) 17, 19, 20, 32, aside from flavanols such as epicatechin, which can reach micromolar concentrations 20. For example, following consumption of 500 mg of the anthocyanin C3G, the phenolic metabolite VA was found to peak at 1.8 μM and persisted at levels of 1 μM for up to 24 h. Similarly, total phenolic metabolites reached cumulative concentrations of 10 μM, in opposition to C3G that reached a peak serum concentration of only 0.1 μM 17, 19. Comparable individual and cumulative plasma concentrations have been reported in studies feeding flavan‐3‐ols, flavanones, and flavonols 22, 23, 39. A 100 μM treatment was also included in the present study to represent a pharmacological dose to reflect maximal responses observed in the literature. Interestingly, doses of 1 μM were consistently the most bioactive of the concentrations tested (Table 2) and when looking across the range of concentrations, U‐shaped trends were often present. These bimodal effects are typical for many phytochemicals 40 and in small dose ranges will appear as either a U‐shaped or inverse U‐shaped dose–response, depending on what part of the curve you capture. The bimodal actions of quercetin have previously been reported in in vitro studies of basophil function 41. In addition, bimodal increases in flow‐mediated dilatation were observed in healthy human volunteers consuming various doses of a beverage rich in blueberries 42, and similar observations were drawn from a recent systematic review of randomized controlled trials involving flavonoid interventions 43.
In the present study, we investigated the effect of the six precursor flavonoids, 14 metabolites, and 29 combinations on LPS‐induced TNF‐α protein levels (Table 2). Initially, we screened 49 treatments across four concentrations in triplicate, representing a total of 588 LPS‐induced TNF‐α protein screens. Two precursor flavonoids (P3G and C3G) and five metabolites (IVA, IVA‐glucuronide, BA‐sulfate, PCA‐3‐sulfate, and VA‐glucuronide) reduced TNF‐α secretion in isolation (Table 2). The screen indicated that the flavonoid metabolites appear more active than their precursor structures, suggesting that the metabolism of flavonoids increases bioactivity in this model.
Four treatments comprising combinations of metabolites (at equal molar ratios) containing: PCA and 4HBA; PCA, 4HBA, and VA; 4HBA, BA‐glucuronide, and BA‐sulfate; and PCA and PCA‐3‐glucuronide significantly reduced TNF‐α secretion at 1–10 μM. Previously combination treatments of chrysin and kaempferol have been reported to be active toward LPS‐stimulated RAW 264.7 cells, reducing nitric oxide, prostaglandin E2, and TNF‐α levels 44, however this previous study focused on the effects of combinations of unmetabolized precursor flavonoids, which is less physiologically relevant, as circulating monocytes are unlikely to be exposed to high concentrations of unmetabolized flavonoids 17, 19, particularly as precursor flavonoids are found at much lower concentrations than their metabolites in the systemic circulation 2, 20.
To allow a direct comparison between the treatments containing combinations of metabolites and their individual constituents, each metabolite was studied individually at the concentration it was present at in the active combination (e.g. 0.5 or 0.33 μM) to establish if there effects were additive. Here PCA, 4HBA, and VA were not active in isolation across the dose ranges explored, suggesting additive effects of the compounds when present together.
Treatments that significantly modulated TNF‐α secretion were further explored for their effect on IL‐1β, as with TNF‐α, IL‐1β is a critical mediator in inflammation where blockade inhibits the progression of cardiovascular disease 8. The treatments that were previously indicated as bioactive in the LPS‐induced TNF‐α screen, had no effect on LPS‐stimulated IL‐1β secretion, with the exception of 4HBA, which significantly reduced IL‐1β secretion by 49.6 ± 12.3% (p = 0.011). PCA in isolation also showed a trend toward a reduction in IL‐1β secretion (16.8 ± 15.0%, p = 0.171). Studies by Wei et al. and Monagas et al. have previously reported PCA decreasing IL‐1β secretion in LPS‐stimulated murine lung tissue in vivo, and 4HBA reducing IL‐1β secretion in LPS‐stimulated peripheral mononuclear blood cells 45, 46. These results are interesting as both signaling pathways are regulated by NF‐κB, and therefore a similar response would have been anticipated if flavonoids and combinations regulated transcription. In order to further explore the effect of the significant bioactive treatments, TNF‐α and IL‐1β mRNA expression and NF‐κB activation were investigated. There was no effect on mRNA levels, lending credence to the supposition of a post‐transcriptional mode of action. These results are similar to data reported by other groups 47 showing quercetin to have no effect on TNF‐α or IL‐1β mRNA levels in LPS‐stimulated THP‐1 cells. In addition, none of the treatments affected NF‐κB activation, which is similar to previous studies 47, 48, where several flavonoids including naringenin, hesperetin, and epicatechin (0.1–1 μM) and quercetin (33 μM) had no effect on NF‐κB activation in astrocytes or J3774A.1 mouse macrophages, respectively. In contrast, other studies 48, 49 have shown NF‐κB inhibition following treatment with the flavonoids apigenin and luteolin (30 μM) in HEK293 cells and kaempferol‐3‐O‐glucoside (223 μM) in J3774A.1 mouse macrophages; however, none of these flavonoids were investigated in the present study. In addition, the effect on NF‐κB activation was observed at 30–100 μM concentrations of the treatments, which is three‐ to ten‐fold higher than utilized in the present investigation. NF‐κB inhibition may therefore require higher doses of flavonoids, which are likely beyond that of which is physiologically relevant 50 following habitual dietary intake. The effects of the active treatments in the LPS‐induced TNF‐α screen were also explored for their ability to modulate IL‐10 secretion as previously other groups have shown changes in IL‐10 levels 12, 13 following treatment of PMA‐differentiated THP‐1 cells with quince peel extract 12. However, we saw no change in IL‐10 protein secretion compared to the VC. This was also observed in mice fed flavonoid‐rich citrus peel extract for 6 wk 13. IL‐10 is also regulated by NF‐κB.
The protein, mRNA, and reporter assay data all indicate that the flavonoids, metabolites, and combinations act on TNF‐α after transcription. One possible target for future investigation is TNF‐α converting enzyme (TACE). TACE is involved in the post‐translation processing of TNF‐α protein and its activity has been reported to be modulated by the flavonoids rutin, orientin, and isoorietin 51, 52. In contrast, Catalan et al. showed that polyphenol‐rich peanut extract had no significant effect 53; however, future studies should focus on the activity of flavonoid metabolites on TACE. Modulation of TACE would provide an explanation for the different effects between the cytokines, as TACE regulates the post‐translational processing of TNF‐α 54, but has no effect on IL‐1β or IL‐10. IL‐1β 55 is cleaved by caspase 1 to produce its mature soluble form and IL‐10 is not post‐translationally modified 56. Another possible mechanism of action of the flavonoids is inhibition of p38 MAP kinase. p38 MAP kinase regulates TNF‐α protein but not mRNA expression 57 and flavonoids, including procyanidins and epigallocatechin gallate, have previously been reported to inhibit LPS‐induced p38 MAP kinase phosphorylation in macrophages 58, 59, 60, suggesting that this may be a potential mechanism for the inhibitory effects of the flavonoid metabolites on TNF‐α protein but not mRNA expression. These potential mechanisms warrant further investigation.
The present study is not without limitations, most notably, the basic screening model utilized. Cell culture screening methodologies utilizing a pharmacological stimulus such as LPS are most responsive to pharmacologically active substances that have pronounced effects on protein and mRNA expression. Titrating these stimuli to levels, which are more appropriate for studying dietary phytochemical activity, produces less responsive systems, ultimately lowering the dynamic range of the assay, resulting in a larger variability between experiments. Therefore, standard screening models may be less effective in identifying the activity of low concentrations of dietary phytochemicals, which was reflected in the present study by the relatively low responses of the treatments.
The present screen of flavonoid metabolites in isolation and in combination, at low micromolar concentrations, is a novel design and provides an important contribution to the field, as it aims to explore the activity of a group of physiologically relevant phytochemical metabolites at appropriate concentrations. The study of complex mixtures of metabolites, in addition to utilizing pure synthesized metabolites is also quite unique. However, as there is a substantially high day‐to‐day variation in dietary flavonoid consumption between individuals, and enormous interindividual variation reported for the absorption, distribution, metabolism, and elimination of flavonoids 17, 19, designing a treatment that entirely mimics plasma composition is unrealistic. Because of this actuality, we selected a more practical approach of exploring the activity of a number of simple and complex mixtures of structurally similar flavonoids and metabolites across a concentration range, in order to gain insight into structure–activity relationships and additive and/or synergistic activities. As the concentrations of each individual analyte would differ with diet and individual, it was also practical to use equal concentrations of the analytes in the mixtures. Most in vitro studies in the past have investigated the actions of supraphysiological concentrations of precursor flavonoids in isolation, or using crude fruit or serum extracts. Here, our screen has revealed possible modes of action of flavonoid metabolites, however, further work is needed to fully ascertain the mechanisms of action. Interestingly, the greatest activities observed appeared to be at the lowest concentrations investigated and appeared nonlinear, which could suggest high‐dose interventions may not be necessary for prevention or disease risk‐reduction. Ultimately, the present study suggests that the health benefits observed in epidemiological studies, which have been accredited to flavonoid consumption, may be the result of the activity of complex combinations of flavonoids and their metabolites, as found in the systemic circulation following normal dietary consumption.
In conclusion, we have shown that some metabolites of flavonoids individually and in combination appear more bioactive then their precursor flavonoids, at equivalent concentrations. In time, these data may help establish appropriate combinations of flavonoid‐rich foods for utilization in animal and human trials exploring dietary strategies for cardio‐protection.
Supporting information
Table S1 Effect of treatments on LPS‐induced TNF‐α protein secretion with including all data and p values.
Table S2. Effect of treatments on IL‐1β protein expression including p values.
Acknowledgments
C.D.K., M.A.O.C., and D.O.H. designed the study. J.L.D.G., J.S.K., Q.Z., K.S.R., and S.K.Y. performed the laboratory work. J.L.D.G. analyzed the data and wrote the manuscript. J.L.D.G., C.D.K., and M.A.O.C. edited the manuscript. M.A.O.C. and C.D.K. had primary responsibility for the final manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
This study was supported by funding from the UK Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council Diet and Health Research Industry Club (BBSRC‐DRINC) (BB/I006028/1) and by a studentship grant (BB/J500100/1).
The authors have declared no conflict of interest.
References
- 1.
Perez‐Jimenez, J. ,Neveu, V. ,Vos, F. ,Scalbert, A. , Systematic analysis of the content of 502 polyphenols in 452 foods and beverages: an application of the phenol‐explorer database. J. Agr. Food Chem.2010, 58, 4959–4969.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 2.
Manach, C. ,Scalbert, A. ,Morand, C. ,Remesy, C. et al., Polyphenols: food sources and bioavailability. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.2004, 79, 727–747.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 3.
Cassidy, A. ,O'Reilly, E. J. ,Kay, C. ,Sampson, L. et al., Habitual intake of flavonoid subclasses and incident hypertension in adults. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.2011, 93, 338–347.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 4.
Hamaguchi, T. ,Ono, K. ,Murase, A. ,Yamada, M. , Phenolic compounds prevent Alzheimer's pathology through different effects on the amyloid‐beta aggregation pathway. Am. J. Pathol.2009, 175, 2557–2565.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 5.
Spatafora, C. ,Tringali, C. , Natural‐derived polyphenols as potential anticancer agents. Anticancer Agents Med. Chem.2012, 12, 902–918.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 6.
Candore, G. ,Caruso, C. ,Jirillo, E. ,Magrone, T. et al., Low grade inflammation as a common pathogenetic denominator in age‐related diseases: novel drug targets for anti‐ageing strategies and successful ageing achievement. Curr. Pharm. Des.2010, 16, 584–596.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 7.
Wu, J. J. ,Poon, K. Y. ,Channual, J. C. ,Shen, A. Y. , Association between tumor necrosis factor inhibitor therapy and myocardial infarction risk in patients with psoriasis. Arch. Dermatol.2012, 148, 1244–1250.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 8.
Abbate, A. ,Van Tassell, B. W. ,Biondi‐Zoccai, G. G. , Blocking interleukin‐1 as a novel therapeutic strategy for secondary prevention of cardiovascular events. BioDrugs2012, 26, 217–233.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 9.
Egert, S. ,Boesch‐Saadatmandi, C. ,Wolffram, S. ,Rimbach, G. et al., Serum lipid and blood pressure responses to quercetin vary in overweight patients by apolipoprotein E genotype. J. Nutr.2010, 140, 278–284.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 10.
Yuan, L. ,Zhou, X. ,Li, D. ,Ma, W. et al., Pattern recognition receptors involved in the inflammatory attenuating effects of soybean isoflavone in beta‐amyloid peptides 1–42 treated rats. Neurosci. Lett.2012, 506, 266–270.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 11.
Ha, S. K. ,Park, H. Y. ,Eom, H. ,Kim, Y. et al., Narirutin fraction from citrus peels attenuates LPS‐stimulated inflammatory response through inhibition of NF‐kappaB and MAPKs activation. Food Chem. Toxicol.2012, 50, 3498–3504.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 12.
Essafi‐Benkhadir, K. ,Refai, A. ,Riahi, I. ,Fattouch, S. et al., Quince (Cydonia oblonga Miller) peel polyphenols modulate LPS‐induced inflammation in human THP‐1‐derived macrophages through NF‐kappaB, p38MAPK and Akt inhibition. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun.2012, 418, 180–185.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 13.
Park, H. J. ,Jung, U. J. ,Cho, S. J. ,Jung, H. K. et al., Citrus unshiu peel extract ameliorates hyperglycemia and hepatic steatosis by altering inflammation and hepatic glucose‐ and lipid‐regulating enzymes in db/db mice. J. Nutr. Biochem.2013, 24, 419–427.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 14.
Lai, W. W. ,Hsu, S. C. ,Chueh, F. S. ,Chen, Y. Y. et al., Quercetin inhibits migration and invasion of SAS human oral cancer cells through inhibition of NF‐kappaB and matrix metalloproteinase‐2/‐9 signaling pathways. Anticancer Res.2013, 33, 1941–1950.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 15.
Speciale, A. ,Canali, R. ,Chirafisi, J. ,Saija, A. et al., Cyanidin‐3‐O‐glucoside protection against TNF‐alpha‐induced endothelial dysfunction: involvement of nuclear factor‐kappaB signaling. J. Agr. Food Chem.2010, 58, 12048–12054.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 16.
Del Rio, D. ,Rodriguez‐Mateos, A. ,Spencer, J. P. ,Tognolini, M. et al., Dietary (poly)phenolics in human health: structures, bioavailability, and evidence of protective effects against chronic diseases. Antioxid. Redox Signal.2013, 18, 1818–1892.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 17.
de Ferrars, R. M. ,Czank, C. ,Zhang, Q. ,Botting, N. P. et al., The pharmacokinetics of anthocyanins and their metabolites in humans. Brit. J. Pharmacol.2014, 171, 3268–3282.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 18.
Crozier, A. , Absorption, metabolism, and excretion of (‐)‐epicatechin in humans: an evaluation of recent findings. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.2013, 98, 861–862.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 19.
Czank, C. ,Cassidy, A. ,Zhang, Q. ,Morrison, D. J. et al., Human metabolism and elimination of the anthocyanin, cyanidin‐3‐glucoside: a (13)C‐tracer study. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.2013, 97, 995–1003.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 20.
Manach, C. ,Williamson, G. ,Morand, C. ,Scalbert, A. et al., Bioavailability and bioefficacy of polyphenols in humans. I. Review of 97 bioavailability studies. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.2005, 81, 230S–242S.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 21.
Ogborne, R. M. ,Rushworth, S. A. ,O'Connell, M. A. , Epigallocatechin activates haem oxygenase‐1 expression via protein kinase Cdelta and Nrf2. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun.2008, 373, 584–588.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 22.
Urpi‐Sarda, M. ,Monagas, M. ,Khan, N. ,Llorach, R. et al., Targeted metabolic profiling of phenolics in urine and plasma after regular consumption of cocoa by liquid chromatography‐tandem mass spectrometry. J. Chromatogr. A2009, 1216, 7258–7267.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 23.
Rios, L. Y. ,Gonthier, M. P. ,Remesy, C. ,Mila, I. et al., Chocolate intake increases urinary excretion of polyphenol‐derived phenolic acids in healthy human subjects. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.2003, 77, 912–918.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 24.
Zhang, Q. ,Raheem, K. S. ,Botting, N. P. ,Slawin, A. M. Z. et al., Flavonoid metabolism: the synthesis of phenolic glucuronides and sulfates as candidate metabolites for bioactivity studies of dietary flavonoids. Tetrahedron2012, 68, 4194–4201.[Google Scholar] - 25.
Steel, R. ,Cowan, J. ,Payerne, E. ,O'Connell, M. A. et al., Anti‐inflammatory effect of a cell‐penetrating peptide targeting the Nrf2/Keap1 interaction. ACS Med. Chem. Lett.2012, 3, 407–410.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 26.
Wang, X. J. ,Hayes, J. D. ,Henderson, C. J. ,Wolf, C. R. , Identification of retinoic acid as an inhibitor of transcription factor Nrf2 through activation of retinoic acid receptor alpha. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. US A2007, 104, 19589–19594.[Google Scholar] - 27.
Speciale, A. ,Chirafisi, J. ,Saija, A. ,Cimino, F. , Nutritional antioxidants and adaptive cell responses: an update. Curr. Mol. Med.2011, 11, 770–789.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 28.
Bhardwaj, P. ,Khanna, D. , Green tea catechins: defensive role in cardiovascular disorders. Chin. J. Nat. Med.2013, 11, 345–353.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 29.
Latif, R. , Health benefits of cocoa. Curr. Opin. Clin. Nutr. Metab. Care2013, 16, 669–674.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 30.
Gonzalez‐Gallego, J. ,Garcia‐Mediavilla, M. V. ,Sanchez‐Campos, S. ,Tunon, M. J. , Fruit polyphenols, immunity and inflammation. Brit. J. Nutr.2010, 104(Suppl 3), S15–S27.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 31.
Hooper, L. ,Kroon, P. A. ,Rimm, E. B. ,Cohn, J. S. et al., Flavonoids, flavonoid‐rich foods, and cardiovascular risk: a meta‐analysis of randomized controlled trials. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.2008, 88, 38–50.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 32.
Rodriguez‐Mateos, A. ,Pino‐Garcia, R. D. ,George, T. W. ,Vidal‐Diez, A. et al., Impact of processing on the bioavailability and vascular effects of blueberry (poly)phenols. Mol. Nutr. Food Res.2014, 58, 1952–1961.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 33.
Zamora‐Ros, R. ,Andres‐Lacueva, C. ,Lamuela‐Raventos, R. M. ,Berenguer, T. et al., Estimation of dietary sources and flavonoid intake in a Spanish adult population (EPIC‐Spain). J. Am. Diet. Assoc.2010, 110, 390–398.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 34.
Chun, O. K. ,Chung, S. J. ,Song, W. O. , Estimated dietary flavonoid intake and major food sources of U.S. adults. J. Nutr.2007, 137, 1244–1252.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 35.
Mullie, P. ,Clarys, P. ,Deriemaeker, P. ,Hebbelinck, M. , Estimation of daily human intake of food flavonoids. Plant Food. Hum. Nutr.2007, 62, 93–98.[Google Scholar] - 36.
Vitaglione, P. ,Donnarumma, G. ,Napolitano, A. ,Galvano, F. et al., Protocatechuic acid is the major human metabolite of cyanidin‐glucosides. J. Nutr.2007, 137, 2043–2048.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 37.
Schär, M. Y. ,Curtis, P. J. ,Hazim, S. Ostertag, L. M. et al., Orange juice‐derived flavanone and phenolic metabolites do not acutely affect cardiovascular risk biomarkers: a randomized, placebo‐controlled, crossover trial in men at moderate risk of cardiovascular disease. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.2015. doi: 10.3945/ajcn.114.104364.[Google Scholar] - 38.
Hernandez, L. ,Afonso, D. ,Rodriguez, E. M. ,Diaz, C. , Phenolic compounds in wheat grain cultivars. Plant Food. Hum. Nutr.2011, 66, 408–415.[Google Scholar] - 39.
Wiese, S. ,Esatbeyoglu, T. ,Winterhalter, P. ,Kruse, H. P. et al., Comparative biokinetics and metabolism of pure monomeric, dimeric and polymeric flavan‐3‐ols: a randomized cross‐over study in humans. Mol. Nutr. Food Res.2014, 59, 610–621.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 40.
Chirumbolo, S. , Plant phytochemicals as new potential drugs for immune disorders and cancer therapy: really a promising path?J. Sci. Food Agr.2012, 92, 1573–1577.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 41.
Chirumbolo, S. ,Marzotto, M. ,Conforti, A. ,Vella, A. et al., Bimodal action of the flavonoid quercetin on basophil function: an investigation of the putative biochemical targets. Clin. Mol. Allergy2010, 8, 13–25.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 42.
Rodriguez‐Mateos, A. ,Rendeiro, C. ,Bergillos‐Meca, T. ,Tabatabaee, S. et al., Intake and time dependence of blueberry flavonoid‐induced improvements in vascular function: a randomized, controlled, double‐blind, crossover intervention study with mechanistic insights into biological activity. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.2013, 98, 1179–1191.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 43.
Kay, C. D. ,Hooper, L. ,Kroon, P. A. ,Rimm, E. B. et al., Relative impact of flavonoid composition, dose and structure on vascular function: a systematic review of randomised controlled trials of flavonoid‐rich food products. Mol. Nutr. Food Res.2012, 56, 1605–1616.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 44.
Harasstani, O. A. ,Moin, S. ,Tham, C. L. ,Liew, C. Y. et al., Flavonoid combinations cause synergistic inhibition of proinflammatory mediator secretion from lipopolysaccharide‐induced RAW 264.7 cells. Inflamm. Res2010, 59, 711–721.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 45.
Monagas, M. ,Khan, N. ,Andres‐Lacueva, C. ,Urpi‐Sarda, M. et al., Dihydroxylated phenolic acids derived from microbial metabolism reduce lipopolysaccharide‐stimulated cytokine secretion by human peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Brit. J. Nutr.2009, 102, 201–206.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 46.
Wei, M. ,Chu, X. ,Jiang, L. ,Yang, X. et al., Protocatechuic acid attenuates lipolysaccharide‐induced acute lung injury. Inflammation2012, 35, 1169–1178.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 47.
Chanput, W. ,Mes, J. ,Vreeburg, R. A. ,Savelkoul, H. F. et al., Transcription profiles of LPS‐stimulated THP‐1 monocytes and macrophages: a tool to study inflammation modulating effects of food‐derived compounds. Food Funct.2010, 1, 254–261.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 48.
Vogl, S. ,Atanasov, A. G. ,Binder, M. ,Bulusu, M. et al., The Herbal Drug Melampyrum pratense L. (Koch): isolation and identification of its bioactive compounds targeting mediators of inflammation. Evid. Based Complement. Alternat. Med2013, 2013, 1–10.[Google Scholar] - 49.
Kim, M. S. ,Kim, S. H. , Inhibitory effect of astragalin on expression of lipopolysaccharide‐induced inflammatory mediators through NF‐kappaB in macrophages. Arch. Pharmacal. Res.2011, 34, 2101–2107.[Google Scholar] - 50.
Erlund, I. ,Freese, R. ,Marniemi, J. ,Hakala, P. et al., Bioavailability of quercetin from berries and the diet. Nutr. Cancer2006, 54, 13–17.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 51.
Lee, W. ,Ku, S. K. ,Bae, J. S. , Vascular barrier protective effects of orientin and isoorientin in LPS‐induced inflammation in vitro and in vivo. Vasc. Pharmacol.2014, 62, 3–14.[Google Scholar] - 52.
Ku, S. K. ,Lee, I. C. ,Han, M. S. ,Bae, J. S. , Inhibitory effects of rutin on the endothelial protein C receptor shedding in vitro and in vivo. Inflammation2014, 37, 1424–1431.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 53.
Catalan, U. ,Fernandez‐Castillejo, S. ,Angles, N. ,Morello, J. R. et al., Inhibition of the transcription factor c‐Jun by the MAPK family, and not the NF‐kappaB pathway, suggests that peanut extract has anti‐inflammatory properties. Mol. Immunol.2012, 52, 125–132.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 54.
Hehlgans, T. ,Pfeffer, K. , The intriguing biology of the tumour necrosis factor/tumour necrosis factor receptor superfamily: players, rules and the games. Immunology2005, 115, 1–20.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 55.
Black, R. A. ,Kronheim, S. R. ,Cantrell, M. ,Deeley, M. C. et al., Generation of biologically active interleukin‐1 beta by proteolytic cleavage of the inactive precursor. J. Biol. Chem.1988, 263, 9437–9442.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 56.
Ouyang, W. ,Rutz, S. ,Crellin, N. K. ,Valdez, P. A. et al., Regulation and functions of the IL‐10 family of cytokines in inflammation and disease. Annu. Rev. Immunol.2011, 29, 71–109.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 57.
Giambelluca, M. S. ,Cloutier, N. ,Rollet‐Labelle, E. ,Boilard, E. et al., Expression and regulation of glycogen synthase kinase 3 in human neutrophils. Int. J. Biochem. Cell Biol.2013, 45, 2660–2665.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 58.
Bak, M. J. ,Truong, V. L. ,Kang, H. S. ,Jun, M. et al., Anti‐inflammatory effect of procyanidins from wild grape (Vitis amurensis) seeds in LPS‐induced RAW 264.7 cells. Oxid. Med. Cell. Longev.2013, 2013, 1–11.[Google Scholar] - 59.
Joo, S. Y. ,Song, Y. A. ,Park, Y. L. ,Myung, E. et al., Epigallocatechin‐3‐gallate inhibits LPS‐induced NF‐kappaB and MAPK signaling pathways in bone marrow‐derived macrophages. Gut Liver2012, 6, 188–196.[PubMed][Google Scholar] - 60.
Ichikawa, D. ,Matsui, A. ,Imai, M. ,Sonoda, Y. et al., Effect of various catechins on the IL‐12p40 production by murine peritoneal macrophages and a macrophage cell line, J774.1. Biol. Pharmaceut. Bull.2004, 27, 1353–1358.[Google Scholar]